
The U.S. Supreme Court declined on November 16 to hear a challenge to California's continuing medical education rules, leaving in place a Ninth Circuit decision that found the state's courses count as government speech. The case, Khatibi v. Yip, has now reached its end, but not without a sharp dissent from Justice Clarence Thomas warning that the ruling could let states strip First Amendment protections from entire professions simply by regulating them heavily enough.
What the Court Did — and Didn't Do
The justices denied the petition for a writ of certiorari brought by Azadeh Khatibi and Do No Harm, meaning the Supreme Court issued no new nationwide standard in the case, according to the opinion published by law.cornell.edu. Justice Thomas dissented from that denial, and Justice Samuel Alito joined him. Justice Neil Gorsuch, separately, said he would have granted the petition — though the dissent does not establish that Gorsuch joined Thomas's reasoning. As Tampa Free Press reported, the combined positions of Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch signal interest in revisiting the 2022 precedent at the center of the dispute.
Khatibi and her fellow challengers, represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation, argued that requiring implicit-bias instruction in continuing medical education amounts to unconstitutional compelled speech. California-licensed physicians must complete 50 hours of approved continuing medical education every two years, and the courses are often organized by private entities, certified by private accreditors, and taught by private instructors, per the opinion. The state does not preapprove course content, the opinion notes, but it reserves the right to audit courses for compliance with its standards.
A Conflict Over Scope
Sources differ on exactly how far California's implicit-bias requirement reaches. The Supreme Court opinion describes a 2019 state law requiring that, after January 1, 2022, all continuing medical education courses must contain curriculum covering the understanding of implicit bias. The Pacific Legal Foundation, however, describes the underlying law, AB 241, as applying specifically to continuing medical education courses involving direct patient care, per pacificlegal.org. The California training rule remains in effect regardless of which description controls.
The Ninth Circuit had held that continuing medical education courses eligible for California Medical Board credit constitute government speech, applying a framework the Supreme Court set out in its 2022 ruling in Shurtleff v. Boston. That ruling found Boston violated the First Amendment when it refused a Christian group's request to fly a religious flag outside City Hall, with the justices concluding the city's flag-raising program was not government speech. Shurtleff established a three-factor test for identifying government speech — the history of the expression, how the public perceives the speaker, and the degree of government control over the message — as described by Newsweek.
Thomas: Shurtleff Is 'Leading Courts Astray'
In his dissent, Thomas argued the Ninth Circuit blurred the boundary between government speech and private expression, giving excessive weight to the state's medical-licensing authority while misclassifying private classroom instruction as speech by the government itself. He wrote that the appeals court failed to distinguish genuine government speech from the regulation of private expression, and said the government-speech doctrine covers only a narrow part of constitutional law.
“First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech,” Thomas wrote, according to the opinion. He said the Court should reconsider whether the Shurtleff test is the proper way to identify government speech, arguing more broadly that the First Amendment protects free speech against government interference but does not prevent government from speaking for itself. Thomas warned that under the Ninth Circuit's reasoning, states could eliminate First Amendment protections across industries simply by regulating them heavily enough. He noted that he and Alito had raised a similar concern in a 2022 opinion about lower courts misclassifying heavily regulated private speech as government speech.
Pacific Legal Foundation Vows to Keep Fighting
Caleb Trotter, an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation who helped represent the challengers, said the lower court's reasoning could extend well beyond medical education if left unchecked. He said the foundation will continue opposing requirements that force professionals to endorse government orthodoxy simply to practice their trade.
For now, the Ninth Circuit ruling remains in effect, and California's continuing medical education standards — set broadly by state officials, with private organizations designing, accrediting, and teaching the actual courses — stand unchanged. The state still audits courses for compliance, but, per the opinion, private organizations receive no state sign-off on every lesson before teaching it. With the Supreme Court declining to weigh in, that arrangement will continue, even as Thomas's dissent leaves open the question of whether a future case could force the justices to revisit it.









