Seattle/ Food & Drinks

Tacoma's Legendary Doughnuts Shuts Sixth Avenue Shop After 14 Years

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Tacoma's Legendary Doughnuts Shuts Sixth Avenue Shop After 14 YearsSixth Ave. — Tacoma Doughnuts Commercial Corridor
Google Street View

Legendary Doughnuts served its final doughnuts at 2602 6th Ave. in Tacoma on Sunday, closing the book on a 14-year run in the neighborhood. Families with kids in tow and longtime regulars packed the shop on its last day, and by the time the lights went out, the store had sold out and posted a thank-you to customers for their support.

The closure caps months of friction between the shop's owners and the building's co-owner over lease terms. As reported by MyNorthwest.com, owner Shannon Patten said the landlord sought to raise the shop's rent by around $1,800 per month, and she called the closure, per the Puget Sound Business Journal, a very sad and difficult time. Patten said she turned down an 18-month lease after months of negotiations, after which Legendary held a month-to-month lease agreement instead.

Dueling Accounts of the Rent Fight

Accounts of exactly how big that rent increase was differ depending on the source. The News Tribune reported Patten's camp put the figure at approximately $1,800, while the newsletter Tacoma Local Minute described it as nearly $2,000 a month. The two outlets also disagree on how long Legendary had been operating month-to-month: Patten told the paper it dated back to November 2025, while Tacoma Local Minute's account said the arrangement had lasted several years.

Andrew Taylor, who co-owns the property, offered his own version of events. He said he was seeking more stability and opted to slightly increase the monthly rent, which he said was already below market value, and that the increase reflected the added risk of a month-to-month arrangement, according to the same Puget Sound Business Journal reporting cited by MyNorthwest. Taylor said he is now looking for a new local tenant for the space.

A Doughnut Rival Moving In Nearby

Taylor also pointed to a competitive wrinkle shaping the negotiations: Legendary's owners would not consider a three- or five-year lease, he said, due at least in part to the potential impact of Voodoo Doughnuts, which has planned to open its first Tacoma store just a block away from Legendary's old spot, the newspaper reported. That Portland-based chain, founded in 2003, has grown to more than two dozen locations in several states and had been expected to bring its brand to 2702 6th Ave., expanding its presence in Washington beyond Vancouver and Seattle.

Shannon and Ken Patten had signaled trouble was brewing well before the shop's final weekend. In Facebook and Instagram posts earlier this month, the couple said the last few years have been quite a struggle for them at the Sixth Avenue location, citing pandemic-related fallout, tighter household budgets and rising rent and prices on top of everything else.

Other Shops Staying Open

Despite the Tacoma closure, the Pattens assured fans that their other locations were all good. Legendary Doughnuts has seven remaining locations, in Kent, Covington, Auburn, Puyallup, Federal Way, Orting and Issaquah. The company got its start in Auburn in 2010, near the couple's home, before the Tacoma outpost followed two years later in 2012.

For now, Legendary says it hopes to find another location in the future, according to Patten. Tacoma customers who showed up Sunday, some with kids in hand, got one last taste of a shop that had anchored that stretch of Sixth Avenue for more than a decade before the doors closed for good.