
Houston ISD is free to keep paying teachers under its performance-based raise system for now, after a Texas appeals court tossed out a lawsuit filed by the district's largest teachers union. The Texas First Court of Appeals dismissed the Houston Federation of Teachers' challenge to HISD's teacher pay plan on Tuesday, lifting a lower court order that had frozen the district's use of certain state funds.
The ruling, issued Tuesday, vacated a temporary injunction that had blocked HISD from spending state money for anything other than its stated purpose, according to Chron. The appeals court also found that the union had failed to exhaust administrative remedies through the Texas Education Agency before taking the fight to court, per the same report. HISD Superintendent Mike Miles said the district had won its battle to keep using a pay-for-performance structure, telling attendees at a district advisory committee meeting Tuesday night in Houston that the ruling affirmed the district's approach.
What the Lawsuit Was Actually About
At the center of the dispute is the Teacher Retention Allotment, created by the Texas Legislature under House Bill 2 for the 2025-26 school year. Under state law, districts with more than 5,000 students must provide guaranteed raises based on years of experience, set at $2,500 for teachers with three to four years on the job and $5,000 for those with five or more years, according to the Houston Chronicle.
The teachers union argued HISD was legally required to distribute those allotment funds strictly according to tenure, and that the district's raises left out eligible teachers who should have received the tenure-based bump. The union further contended that HISD was ineligible to apply for an enhanced pay program without a fully approved local teacher designation system in place, and that district officials acted outside their legal authority in moving forward anyway. The union also argued it needed immediate court relief because the TEA commissioner cannot issue injunctions, the Chronicle's report notes.
The appeals court rejected those arguments. Justice Susanna Dokupil, who wrote the opinion, found that state law actually gives HISD discretion to choose between the available alternatives and allows performance pay even while a district's application for enhanced status is still pending without final state approval.
A Teacher's Pay Fell Short of Expectations
The dispute wasn't purely theoretical for teachers caught in the middle. One 19-year veteran teacher testified that his 2025-26 contract included a $2,000 raise instead of the $5,000 he expected under the tenure-based formula, the Chronicle reported. That raise broke down into $500 from a standard step increase and $1,500 tied to his performance review from the prior year, rather than the flat experience-based bump state law outlines for teachers with five-plus years of service.
HISD's Broader Pay Plan and What's Still Unsettled
HISD had previously signaled it wanted to distribute state-funded raises based on evaluation ratings from the 2024-25 school year, citing a legal exception available to districts applying for special status with the state, according to the Chronicle's earlier reporting. The Texas Education Agency had told the district it would issue final approval or denial of HISD's local teacher designation system in February 2026.
That fight over the Teacher Retention Allotment is tied to a much larger overhaul Miles has pushed for HISD. Under the broader pay-for-performance system the district has outlined, teacher salaries could range from $64,000 to $101,000 a year depending largely on performance ratings, with the full system slated to take effect starting with the 2026-27 school year, according to Houston Landing. Teachers at schools under HISD's overhaul model would also receive annual supplements of either $3,000 or $9,000 depending on their subject area, with the formula weighing administrator classroom observations and student standardized-test gains most heavily. Houston Landing noted that HISD had not yet released full budgetary details for the plan.
HISD's approach stands apart from how nearby districts have handled the same state mandate. Houston Public Media has reported that neighboring Cy-Fair, Fort Bend and Katy school districts raised teacher salaries based on experience, the more traditional route under the state allotment.
Federal Guidance on Who Qualifies
Separately, the Texas Education Agency has clarified that the Teacher Retention Allotment is not limited to certified teachers of record. Per the agency's guidance, the term covers individuals who meet the specified teaching-role requirement even without holding a certificate, though it does not extend to a teacher's aide.
For now, the appeals court's dismissal means HISD can keep spending the disputed state funds as planned while the broader performance-pay rollout continues to take shape.









