Knoxville/ Politics & Govt

Three East Tennessee Contractors Pay Over $1M in PPP Double-Billing Settlement

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Three East Tennessee Contractors Pay Over $1M in PPP Double-Billing SettlementSource: w_lemay / Wikimedia Commons

Three government contractors based in East Tennessee have agreed to pay more than $1 million combined to settle federal allegations that they deceptively obtained forgiveness of their Paycheck Protection Program loans. The settlements, totaling $1,005,186, resolve claims that the companies certified payroll costs on their loan-forgiveness applications even though those same costs had already been billed to — and paid by — the U.S. Department of Energy.

Three Companies, One Alleged Scheme

According to WVLT, the companies involved held federal contracts directly or indirectly through the Department of Energy and agreed to settle allegations that they deceptively obtained forgiveness of their loans through the Paycheck Protection Program. The three firms named are Maryville-based Firewater Associates, LLC; Oak Ridge-based Lancaster Services, Incorporated; and Manhattan Legacy Services, LLC, according to WBIR.

Notably, the companies' identities carry a wrinkle: while WVLT's reporting refers to the Maryville firm as Firewater Associates, LLC, a Department of Justice search listing instead refers to it as Firewater Investigations, LLC. The discrepancy between the two names has not been resolved in available reporting.

How the Alleged Double-Billing Worked

Following an investigation by the Department of Energy, the Department of Justice said it was found that Firewater, Lancaster Services and Manhattan Legacy Services fraudulently certified that they incurred particular payroll costs, per the same WVLT report. The companies billed the payroll costs to the Department of Energy under existing contracts and were paid for the costs, the station reported — meaning the government may have effectively paid twice for the same payroll expenses once the PPP forgiveness was approved.

The Small Business Administration approved the companies' PPP loan forgiveness applications before the alleged double-billing came to light through the Department of Energy's review. The United States contended that the companies fraudulently certified particular payroll costs in PPP loan-forgiveness applications submitted to the SBA, and the government maintained the companies did not actually sustain the payroll costs they had certified in their individual forgiveness applications.

What Each Company Agreed to Pay

Under the settlement terms reported by WVLT, Firewater Associates agreed to pay $405,186, Lancaster Services agreed to pay $475,000, and Manhattan Legacy Services agreed to pay $125,000 — together totaling just over $1 million. The Paycheck Protection Program was created in March 2020 as part of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act to help eligible small businesses experiencing economic hardship during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The East Tennessee settlements are not the only PPP-related enforcement action the Department of Justice has pursued nationally. In a separate case, a foreign-owned industrial manufacturing company agreed to pay $1.5 million to settle False Claims Act allegations tied to a PPP loan, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. In another, Securiport LLC and Alex Stewart International, LLC agreed to pay a combined $1,816,943 to settle civil False Claims Act allegations, per a separate Department of Justice announcement.