
Tim Heidecker and Gregg Turkington are bringing their long-running fake movie-review franchise to downtown Denver this Wednesday, Nov. 11, when On Cinema Live, The Certified ‘Five Bags of Popcorn’ Tour stops at the Paramount Theatre. The show is currently in the second half of its run, and it arrives carrying the weight of 17 seasons of in-character bickering, movie ratings and tangled personal drama between its two leads.
The Paramount’s Silent-Film Origins
The Paramount Theatre’s documented history begins with its design for silent-film screenings, accompanied by a Wurlitzer organ. According to the Paramount Theatre, the organ was built to produce varied sound effects alongside the picture show. The venue is now hosting this live performance, giving the Denver stop a place in the theater’s present-day programming.
The series, Westword reports, follows fictional versions of Heidecker and co-host Gregg Turkington whose disagreements about movies are only part of the story. Now in its 17th season, On Cinema at the Cinema gives this Denver performance a connection to the ongoing storyline rather than treating it as a separate, stand-alone show.
The touring format changes with the season and the films currently in theaters. Turkington told The Pitch that the live show is “basically just a continuation,” with current theatrical releases supplying the movies they review. He also said the performers must incorporate plot developments from the spring tour into the current run.
How Much of the Live Show Actually Counts
Turkington told The Pitch that live material may become part of the series’ official history, though he also thinks of the performance as “a souvenir of the show.” The format blends improvisation with scripted material, and bits that work can carry forward to later performances.
Turkington also credited the audience’s close attention to the show’s serialized story, saying fans sometimes correctly predict where a season is headed. He described the subscriber-funded HEI network as a way to direct the money coming in toward the product itself, without a traditional distributor.
Two Very Different Film Critics
The comic tension comes partly from the gap between the characters’ attitudes toward film, as Heidecker explained to Westword. His character is largely uninterested in movies, while Turkington’s is consumed by film trivia and statistics. That obsession can extend to narrow rules about what qualifies as a movie, including whether documentaries or musicals count.
The popcorn-bag scale is a running joke, though accounts of its limits differ. Westword says only a small number of films have received fewer than five bags, while The A.V. Club describes the system as one in which “nothing ever scores lower than five.” Heidecker has said that lower ratings often serve less as serious criticism than as a way for the characters to take digs at each other.
A New Name and a Long Comedy History
In the current storyline, Heidecker’s character has reportedly adopted the name New Amato, according to Westword. The role fits a broader pattern of Heidecker playing exaggerated public figures, including parodies of Joe Rogan and Bill Maher and an Alex Jones-style character in a fictionalized version of InfoWars.
Heidecker and Turkington last brought their Two Tims tour through the Rockies in 2021. Westword described that run as alternating satirical stand-up with sincere folk rock, including an encore of “Hot Piss” performed under the name Yellow River Boys. Heidecker recalled one stop at Boulder Theater as “particularly good.”
The current tour’s page at timheidecker.org describes a typical performance as opening with an in-character stand-up set before moving into On Cinema-style segments and multimedia. It lists the usual running time as about 90 to 110 minutes, without an intermission.
For Denver audiences new to Heidecker’s work, his earlier credits include Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Good Job!, where he played Spagett alongside John C. Reilly’s Dr. Steve Brule. He also hosts the weekly live YouTube show Office Hours. Heidecker told Westword that On Cinema gives him a way to process anxieties and life’s fears, and connected his interest in blurred identities and personas to Andy Kaufman. He also described an enduring anger toward power structures, tempered by becoming more sensitive about who deserves to be mocked.









