
An Poitin Stil, the Timonium Irish pub generations of regulars call “The Still,” will close for good Dec. 23 after 27 years on York Road. Its three partners, Dorsey Baldwin, Dr. Bill Mitcherling and Dr. John Mitcherling, are retiring as owner-operators.
The Baltimore Sun reported on Nov. 18 that the pub, at 2323 York Road in Timonium, will shut its doors Dec. 23. The owners opened it using materials they brought back from Ireland.
Baltimore Fishbowl reported on Nov. 17 that Baldwin and the two Mitcherlings opened An Poitin Stil in September 1999, using two shipping containers’ worth of materials the three friends brought back from Ireland.
For Bill Mitcherling, the pub’s Irish fittings were part of a broader effort to honor Baltimore’s own Irish history. In a 2018 profile, he said the idea was to bring Ireland to Baltimore while recognizing Irish traditions and the state’s history dating to the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad. That aim linked the Timonium pub’s imported materials to the city’s 19th-century Irish railroad heritage. Mitcherling described that historical inspiration as central to the pub’s concept.
A Longer History of Irish Baltimore
The Irish American Museum says its West Baltimore rowhouses housed Irish immigrants who arrived in the 1840s after the Great Hunger. That documented settlement history is a separate chapter from The Still’s 27-year story in Timonium.
That West Baltimore history is preserved in part because local residents and preservationists organized to save the homes from demolition. The Irish Railroad Workers Museum traces its beginnings to a 1997 preservation group formed to protect alley houses tied to Irish families who worked in the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad yards. The museum’s surviving 1840s homes offer a more direct record of immigrant life than a modern pub can, while placing Baltimore’s Irish heritage in the same railroad history that inspired The Still. The museum recounts the preservation effort and the workers’ connection to the B&O.
A Final Toast and a Proper Send-Off
The owners plan to mark the end with a final toast at 7 p.m. on Dec. 23, Baltimore Fishbowl reported. Baldwin said the owners had made many friends over the years and wanted to give everyone a proper send-off in the coming weeks. The owners also thanked customers, staff and the local Irish community for their support.
A Baltimore precedent for a pub farewell centered on an owner’s retirement came in 2016, when Patrick’s of Pratt Street announced it would close after a history dating to 1847. Its longtime operator, Patrick Rowley, said he was ready to leave the work behind and focus on his Ireland-tour business. The pub had built unusually close ties with regulars: Rowley said he had given 33 patrons keys so they could enter when it was closed. The Patrick’s farewell echoed the personal ties common to neighborhood pubs.
An Poitin Stil is inviting customers to stop by during its final weeks before the lights go out for good. The pub’s owners have framed the closing not just as an ending, but as a chance for the community that filled its booths and bar stools for 27 years to come back one more time.
Taking a Piece of The Still Home
Patrons will have the chance to obtain select furnishings, décor and memorabilia from inside the pub after it closes, according to Baltimore Fishbowl. Details on how that process will work are expected in the coming weeks.
For now, the countdown is on, with just over a month left before An Poitin Stil, known to so many simply as The Still, pours its very last round.









