
A 57-year-old Toms River man has admitted to fatally shooting his stepdaughter's one-year-old French bulldog while he was supposed to be watching over her, a betrayal of trust that unfolded inside a Berkeley Township home while the dog's owners were away at a wedding. Jeffrey Lentz entered guilty pleas this week to charges tied to the death of the Frenchie, named Ruby, who was shot in the face and died hours later at an emergency animal hospital.
Lentz pleaded guilty on Monday to second-degree possession of a firearm for an unlawful purpose and third-degree animal cruelty, according to jerseyshoreonline.com. Ruby belonged to Lentz's stepdaughter, Nicole Guarino, who left the dog in his care on October 3, 2025, while she and the dog's owners attended a wedding, as reported by Daily Voice.
A 911 Call Led to a Grim Discovery
Police were called to a home on Lyford Court in Berkeley Township around 9:05 p.m. that night for a report involving an animal, according to PIX11. Ruby died at an emergency animal hospital that same night, the outlet's report states.
A subsequent veterinary examination and X-ray revealed a bullet lodged in Ruby's jawbone, and investigators determined Lentz had shot the dog in the face, Daily Voice reports. Lentz was not arrested until a month later, on November 3, 2025, according to the same outlet's account of the case.
Plea Deal Spells Out Prison Time and a Lifetime Pet Ban
Under the plea agreement, prosecutors will recommend five years in New Jersey State Prison on the weapons count, including one year of parole ineligibility, with a concurrent three-year flat sentence on the animal cruelty charge, the report notes. A third charge, tied to a large-capacity ammunition magazine, is set to be dismissed as part of the deal, per the same account.
The agreement also bars Lentz from ever owning, harboring, or living with any animal again, and requires that he have no contact with Ruby's owners going forward. According to NJ.com's original report on the plea, Lentz is expected to be subject to a lifetime pet ownership ban and a prison sentence when the case concludes. Sentencing before Judge Ryan is scheduled for January 22, 2027, per jerseyshoreonline.com's reporting.
Lawmakers Proposed Naming the Date After Ruby's Death
In March, New Jersey lawmakers introduced Assembly Joint Resolution 165 and Senate Joint Resolution 129, seeking to designate October 3 — the day Ruby died — as Companion Animal Cruelty Awareness Day. Both measures remain in committee and have not come up for a vote, according to the same jerseyshoreonline.com report.









