
A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit filed by a Trinidad kindergartner and her parents over an alleged January 2025 arm injury at Fisher's Peak Elementary School. The Denver Gazette described the allegations as “troubling,” but U.S. District Court Judge Daniel D. Domenico concluded they did not plausibly establish violations of the girl's federal rights, according to The Denver Gazette.
The girl, identified in court filings as A.H., was in kindergarten at Fisher's Peak Elementary during the 2024-2025 school year and had diagnosed mood disorders associated with hyperactivity, aggression and difficulty regulating emotions, according to Colorado Politics. The district suspended her multiple times in fall 2024 for physical behavior toward other students. Later that year, the district created an individualized education plan and behavioral strategies intended to address risks of harm to A.H. or others.
The complaint alleges that in January 2025, then-assistant principal Rebecca Webber grabbed A.H. by the arm in her classroom and pulled her toward her, dislocating the girl's forearm at the elbow. A.H.'s parents took her to the hospital, and she missed school while recovering, the outlet reported.
Colorado's restraint reporting
For statewide context, the Colorado Department of Education says its 2024-2025 report tracks restraint and seclusion counts by student group statewide and totals for each district. The report provides a way to examine reported use, but those figures do not establish what happened in A.H.'s case: Colorado Department of Education. The department defines physical restraint under state rules as bodily force used to limit a student's voluntary freedom of movement for more than one minute. That definition alone does not determine whether the alleged arm-pull met the threshold.
Parents Sued Over Disability Discrimination Claims
A.H. and her parents sued Webber and Trinidad School District #1, alleging violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act, A.H.'s constitutional right to equal protection and the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, among other claims. Webber and the district asked the court to dismiss the case. Reporting on a Trinidad Police Department form said it indicated no evidence that Webber intended to injure A.H. or handled her improperly or overly aggressively.
The defense argued that A.H. had not identified similarly situated students who were treated differently and that Webber's alleged conduct was a response to A.H.'s behavior, not disability discrimination. A.H.'s attorneys argued that Webber acted out of frustration and animus toward the girl because of her disabilities and how they manifested, according to the outlet's reporting.
Judge Finds Allegations Don't Meet Federal Threshold
In an October 28 order, Domenico found that A.H. had not plausibly alleged that a school administrator violated her constitutional rights by injuring her arm. He said the complaint did not identify similarly situated students who were treated differently, weakening the equal-protection claim, and did not explain how Webber intentionally discriminated against A.H. because of her disability, according to The Denver Gazette.
Domenico wrote that Webber might have pulled A.H.'s arm in good faith to restrain her or in response to her behavior. The complaint, he said, gave no reason to assume that frustration with a manifestation of a disability amounts to animus toward a person with a disability. He also acknowledged that one should not yank a small child's arm, according to the same account.
Domenico dismissed A.H.'s lawsuit but allowed her to refile her Colorado-law claims of negligence and discrimination in state court. The ruling addressed whether the complaint plausibly stated federal claims; it does not establish what happened during the classroom encounter.









