Sacramento/ Weather & Environment

Twitchell Island Levee Crew Braces for El Niño Winter That Could Swamp Island 15 Feet Deep

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Twitchell Island Levee Crew Braces for El Niño Winter That Could Swamp Island 15 Feet DeepSacramento City Hall Plaza — Weather Coverage Landmark Backdrop
Google Street View

Twice a day, every day, Rick Carter Jr. climbs into his truck and drives the same 13-mile loop around Twitchell Island, scanning the levees for vertical displacement, falling rocks, low spots and cracks in the road. He is looking for the kinds of warning signs that, left unchecked, could put the below-sea-level island under 15 feet of water at normal tides. With an El Niño-charged winter bearing down on the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, that routine patrol has taken on new urgency.

Carter is superintendent of Reclamation District 1601, a post he has held for three years, according to KCRA. He was born and raised on Twitchell Island, and the job runs in the family: his father, Rick Carter Sr., held the same superintendent position for 30 years before him, the station reports. On his daily rounds, the younger Carter checks the river-facing side of the levee for damage and watches the island side for water coming through or beneath the structure — a levee boil, he knows, can signal a weak spot before it becomes a failure.

Why This Low-Lying Island Matters So Much

Twitchell Island is considered a high-priority location near the western edge of the Delta, sitting in a bowl-shaped depression protected entirely by levees, per the same KCRA report. Decades of farming and drainage caused the island’s peat soils to break down and sink, leaving it below sea level and exposed to pressure from Pacific water on one side. Officials say a levee failure could also put neighboring islands at risk.

There's a freshwater stake as well. A levee breach could draw saltier water farther into the Delta, threatening both the ecosystem and the freshwater supply that California communities rely on, the station's report notes. Chris Neudeck put it simply: the levee system is what keeps the Delta fresh. He also warned that a two-week succession of atmospheric rivers could fill reservoirs and raise the risk of overflow, a scenario compounded by warm storms that can melt Sierra snow and send even more water down rivers from the east.

What Crews Are Watching For This Winter

Delta levees face a tougher job than most flood-control structures. As one water manager told CalMatters, in the Delta, levees are really more like dams in that they have to hold back water 24-7, rather than just during high-flow events. Wind-driven waves can move the large protective rocks — each weighing 150 to 200 pounds — that line the levees, according to KCRA's reporting. Under normal conditions, levees are inspected daily, but patrols can ramp up to 24 hours a day, seven days a week, run in 12-hour shifts, when tides rise and storms approach, the outlet reports.

Crews are already checking flood-fighting equipment, access roads and levees ahead of the season. On Twitchell Island itself, a levee project is underway that moves a section of levee inland to create a protective buffer, and it's expected to be completed next year, per KCRA. A separate environmental review filed with the state describes Reclamation District 1601's broader plan to build levee improvements along the island's south side, aimed at increasing erosion resistance and adding freeboard for an estimated 4.7-foot wave run-up, according to filings with ceqanet.lci.ca.gov.

A Delta-Wide Repair Bill in the Billions

Twitchell Island is just one piece of a much larger network. The Delta has roughly 1,100 miles of aging levees protecting the region from floods, and the Delta Stewardship Council estimates that repairing them could cost at least $3.2 billion by 2050, the same CalMatters report found. State water officials put the more immediate need at about $1.06 billion for upgrades over just the next five years — while California’s 2026 budget included levee funding and the state vetoed a proposed new funding bill rather than cutting the existing fund from its budget.

Despite the price tag, officials say levee failures are less common than in the past thanks to decades of inspections and improvements, KCRA reports. Still, the Delta's history gives reason for caution. In 2004, a levee failure at Jones Tract flooded 12,000 acres that stayed swamped for months, and during winter storms in early 2023, levees protecting farmland and towns around the Delta sprung leaks, CalMatters reported. Water seeped beneath the levee surrounding Victoria Island in 2024, and crews drove sheet piles deep into the ground to stem the leak.

Older Floods Loom Over This Season's Forecast

The Delta has flooded before when tides and storms lined up. A 1983 flood swamped Mildred Island when King Tides coincided with an atmospheric river, and the island remains underwater to this day, according to KQED. More than 30,000 acres flooded across the Delta in 1986, and the 1997 flood — still the Delta's flood of record — inundated Tyler Island among other places, KQED reports. The outlet notes that in a possible 2026 scenario, a supercharged King Tide could coincide with an atmospheric river, raising Delta water levels up to six feet above normal, with warmer ocean temperatures expected to push tide levels and storm surges higher and make wet, warm storm systems stronger and more frequent. A Delta Stewardship Council report cited by KQED projected that by 2085, a 100-year flood event would expose 21% of the Delta's population and 68% of its land.

What forecasts, flood models and funding can—and can’t—say

NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center says that even with a very strong El Niño, impacts consistent with the pattern are more likely, but not guaranteed. That outlook does not establish whether or when storms will hit Twitchell Island or predict flooding there. The Delta Stewardship Council’s Delta Adapts analysis estimates potential exposure to flooding from levee overtopping; it does not predict or simulate levee-failure scenarios, according to the Climate Prediction Center and the Council’s flood hazard assessment. For levee maintenance and improvements, the Department of Water Resources and the Central Valley Flood Protection Board administer cost-sharing programs with local agencies, including reclamation districts, the Delta Stewardship Council says in its annual report.

San Joaquin County has already faced its own levee scare elsewhere in the Delta. On October 30, 2024, the county declared a local emergency over a potential levee failure along Old River on Victoria Island, after Reclamation District 2040 officials found slumping — a form of erosion — along that levee, KCRA reported at the time. County officials warned a failure there could have damaged farmland, Highway 4 and the area's drinking water. For now, back on Twitchell Island, Carter keeps making his rounds, twice a day, watching the rocks, the water line and the road beneath his tires.