
UnitedHealth Group has sued the federal government over its lowered Medicare Advantage star ratings for 2027, arguing the downgrade threatens imminent harm by stripping away bonus payments and shrinking benefits for patients. The lawsuit, filed Thursday, lands just weeks before Medicare's annual enrollment period closes on December 7, putting pressure on the clock as seniors compare plans for the coming year.
According to Reuters, UnitedHealth's complaint alleges the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services improperly used 26 measures to calculate ratings covering 45 contracts, though Becker's Payer Issues reports the same filing challenges those 26 measures across 51 contracts — the two outlets differ on the exact contract count. The company claims CMS either lacked the statutory authority to use the measures or failed to give it a chance to object, and describes star ratings as the government's principal signal to patients about plan quality.
Per Becker's, the complaint states that 35 of the contracts, serving roughly 2.9 million members, were rated below four stars and would qualify for bonus payments if the disputed measures were tossed out. UnitedHealth has argued that properly calculated ratings should rise by at least half a star and as much as a full one-and-a-half stars. The company has said it remains committed to working with CMS to modernize the Stars program and develop what it calls a durable quality-measurement approach.
How the Star System Shapes Medicare Advantage Payments
Medicare Advantage, known as Part C, is the private-plan alternative for people who opt out of traditional Medicare, available to those 65 and older or living with disabilities. CMS rates these plans on a one-to-five-star scale — poor to excellent — based on health screens, customer satisfaction, and other measures, as the report from STAT explains. Plans rated four stars or higher receive government bonus payments that can reach hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars when costs stay low, while lower ratings can mean smaller benefits and higher premiums for patients, according to the company.
CMS released its 2027 star ratings in October and has declined to comment on the lawsuit. UnitedHealth is the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, holding roughly 30 percent of the market according to the American Medical Association, and served about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients as of September 30. Humana, the second-largest player in the market per the same trade group, filed a similar lawsuit challenging its star ratings back in 2024.
UnitedHealth Joins a Crowded Field of Insurer Lawsuits
UnitedHealth is far from alone in challenging the 2027 ratings. STAT counts it as at least the 15th Medicare Advantage plan to sue CMS over the calculations, while Becker's puts the number at 16 — the discrepancy may reflect differing timing or counting methods, and neither figure is being treated here as the final word. Combined, insurers say their current ratings will cost them more than $4.2 billion in lost bonus payments, per Becker's reporting.
CVS Health sued CMS in October, challenging 28 measures across 43 contracts covering roughly 7 million members, and has said in its own lawsuit that it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention as a result of its ratings. Centene has separately estimated that excluding 17 disputed measures would push its enterprise weighted average from three stars to four, worth about $448 million more in 2028 quality bonus payments and rebate retention, the outlet's report on that lawsuit notes. Elevance, meanwhile, has said excluding the contested measures would lift ratings for 12 of its contracts, potentially yielding roughly $516 million in additional 2028 payments.
A Georgia Court Has Already Sided With One Insurer
Both the UnitedHealth and CVS Health cases were filed in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, and have been assigned to U.S. District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood. That same Brunswick court delivered a win for insurers back in May, when a federal judge ruled that CMS had improperly included 20 measures in Clover Health's 2026 rating — finding the agency lacked authority for 10 of them and had skipped required notice-and-comment rulemaking for the other 10, according to Becker's. A court filing reviewed via the Georgetown Law Litigation Tracker shows Clover had argued that 20 of the 42 measure specifications applied to its 2026 ratings were illegal.
After that ruling, CMS recalculated Clover's largest contract rating, raising it from 3.5 to 4.5 stars, though the agency has since appealed the decision requiring the recalculation, according to Healthcare Finance News. A federal filing tied to that case also noted that CMS had finalized a proposal to phase out certain call-center measures on April 6 of this year. The Clover outcome gives insurers like UnitedHealth a precedent to point to as their own challenges work through the same Georgia courthouse — though whether that case's result will carry over to the newer lawsuits remains to be seen.









