
A Manhattan judge sentenced 58-year-old Gary Sanders to 20 years to life in state prison after a jury convicted him of robbing three elderly Upper East Side residents of their watches in a string of 2024 attacks prosecuted as hate crimes. Each of the victims was followed on the street before Sanders ripped the watch from their wrist, and two of them were left injured.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg announced the sentencing, saying Sanders forcibly stole watches from three people, targeting them based on age and physical condition in separate hate crimes on the Upper East Side. A New York State Supreme Court jury convicted Sanders on all counts on October 8, including two counts of Robbery in the Second Degree as a Hate Crime, one count of Robbery in the Third Degree as a Hate Crime, and one count of False Personation, according to the DA's office.
Three Attacks in One Month
Prosecutors laid out a pattern that repeated itself three times over the course of a single month in 2024. On August 5, Sanders followed a 74-year-old woman as she walked near East 83rd Street and Park Avenue, approached her, and pulled her watch off her left wrist, the DA's office said.
Nineteen days later, on August 24, Sanders followed an 81-year-old man near East 68th Street and Third Avenue and pulled his watch off his left wrist, causing swelling, bruising and pain, per the same account. The pattern repeated a third time on August 31, when Sanders followed an 80-year-old woman near East 75th Street and Park Avenue and pulled her watch off her left wrist, causing swelling and bruising.
All three victims were longtime Upper East Side residents who bravely testified at trial, the DA's office said. Sanders was arrested on September 7, 2024, and the office said he attempted to prevent police officers from accurately identifying him by providing them false personal information.
Charges Carried Hate Crime Enhancements
The DA's office noted that Robbery in the Second Degree as a Hate Crime is a class B felony, while Robbery in the Third Degree as a Hate Crime is a class C felony; the False Personation count is a class B misdemeanor. Sanders had been indicted on October 1, 2024, when he was 56, in connection with the alleged age-based robberies, as reported by 1010 WINS at the time.
Bragg's office credited prosecutors Edward Smith and John Ludtke with handling the case, supervised by Constantine Coritsidis as Deputy Chief of the Hate Crimes Unit, Hannah Yu as Chief of the Hate Crimes Unit, Jeanine Launay as Chief of the Elder Abuse Unit, and Lisa DelPizzo as Chief of the Trial Division. The office also thanked the NYPD, including Detective Daniel Faughnan and Detective Ashley Acevedo of the 19th Precinct Detective Squad and Officer Ronan Whelan of the 19th Precinct.
In a statement promoting the sentencing news, Bragg said Sanders preyed on three unsuspecting older New Yorkers in brazen, broad daylight attacks. Patch similarly reported that Sanders was accused of forcibly stealing valuables and injuring two victims during the attacks.









