
A Ventura County Superior Court judge has ordered former elementary school counselor David Lane Braff Jr. to stand trial on all charges in a case involving allegations from 15 students. The prosecution follows reports of alleged misconduct at a Santa Paula school and a review of Braff’s employment across multiple Southern California school systems.
The Ventura County District Attorney's Office said Braff has been held to answer on all charges following the hearing, which took place on April 28, according to the Ventura County District Attorney's Office. Braff, who was arrested in 2024 and has been jailed since November of that year, has pleaded not guilty, according to KQED. He faces trial for the alleged abuse of 15 students, including 13 from Santa Paula, per the same report.
A Trail Across Five School Systems
The Ventura County District Attorney’s Office said on social media that investigators believe Braff worked for Moorpark Unified School District, Conejo Valley Unified School District, Conejo Recreation and Park District, Ventura Unified School District and Bright Star Schools in Los Angeles. The office cautioned that his full employment history was not known when it made the post.
Local outlet The Acorn reported that Braff worked at McKevett Elementary School from 2015 through 2019. KQED reported that he served as a counselor at the campus for four years. Before then, Braff worked for Conejo Valley Unified School District from September 2003 to April 2015 and for Moorpark Unified School District as a paraeducator and campus supervisor from January 2006 to May 2015, according to The Acorn. KQED also reported that, after the original misconduct report, Braff worked at three additional Southern California schools, including a different Los Angeles elementary school for more than a year before a state review panel decided his case.
Santa Paula's Investigation and a Resignation
Santa Paula Unified School District received complaints from at least seven students alleging that Braff touched them inappropriately, according to KQED. The district's own report described a fifth-grade girl who alleged Braff locked his office door, grabbed her hips and forced her onto his lap, while two girls alleged he touched them near their private parts, per the district report cited by KQED. Braff was recognized as Santa Paula Unified's employee of the month in 2017, the outlet reported, and he acknowledged touching students on the knee during the district's investigation.
The district submitted its findings to the state two months after Braff resigned, a 20-page summary of interviews with at least seven accusers and two witnesses, according to KQED. The district did not initiate discipline against Braff before accepting his resignation, the outlet reported, though Santa Paula Unified did report him to the state and police after conducting its own investigation. The Acorn reported that administrators took immediate action when staff learned of alleged abuse in 2018, placing Braff on administrative leave, contacting Child Protective Services and launching an internal investigation.
A State Panel That Never Forwarded the Case
Braff was first reported to California over 2019 misconduct allegations at McKevett Elementary School, according to KQED, but the state's educator licensing agency conducted what the outlet described as an inadequate investigation. The Committee of Credentials, a seven-member volunteer panel that reviewed Braff's case, did not forward it to the full Commission on Teacher Credentialing for possible discipline, KQED reported. The Committee of Credentials has a role in recommending adverse action in educator cases.
By the time the panel acted, Braff had already moved on to another Los Angeles elementary school, where he worked for more than a year before the Committee of Credentials decided his case, according to KQED. The state didn't suspend his credentials until after his 2024 arrest. Two accusers' struggles were documented by a school administrator in 2022: one had severe anxiety and could not be alone in rooms with men, while another attempted suicide multiple times and spent a year in residential treatment, KQED reported.
One Accuser Says No One Ever Called
Among Braff's accusers is a young woman identified by KQED only as J., now 18. J. and her mother told the outlet that state investigators never contacted her or verified her complaint. KQED reported that state investigators did not interview some students alleging abuse in each case the outlet examined, according to students, parents and attorneys.
A Pattern Seen Elsewhere in California
Braff's case is not the only one KQED and ProPublica's Local Reporting Network identified in which an accused educator kept working after being reported. The outlets said they found at least three educators whom California's licensing agency allowed to keep working in schools until criminal charges were filed, and at least two additional educators reported for sexual misconduct who continued teaching until charges were brought against them.
One of those cases involves Matthew Shelton, a former Benicia elementary school teacher. Shelton was acquitted in a Napa Valley case in 2008; a jury deliberated for just 20 minutes before clearing him, and Benicia Unified hired him months later, according to KQED. The state licensing agency issued Shelton a confidential written warning in 2008 — ultimately an admonishment that, per KQED, is hidden from the public and must be expunged by the state and employers within three years, which is exactly what happened to Shelton's warning.
Students began accusing Shelton of inappropriate touching in 2022, and Benicia Unified and a student's parent reported him to the state commission in 2023. A Benicia parent informed Shelton's next employer, West Contra Costa Unified, about the active police investigation and earlier Napa issues that September, the outlet reported — Shelton had already agreed to resign from Benicia Unified and been hired as an assistant principal at Helms Middle School in that district. Prosecutors charged Shelton in February 2024, triggering an automatic suspension of his credentials, and the state revoked his license outright in July 2024 without waiting for a conviction. He later faced 12 felony counts of alleged lewd acts on four children from his time at Benicia Unified and pleaded not guilty to those charges, per KQED's reporting. A Solano County jury ultimately convicted him of 11 of the 12 counts, with a mistrial declared on the remaining count.
What State Officials Say About the Gaps
Anita Fitzhugh, speaking for the state, told KQED that California automatically revokes teaching credentials when educators are convicted of sexual criminal offenses, but that the state has no written criteria setting the level of adverse action absent a mandatory criminal conviction. California has operated its educator discipline system since the 1970s, Fitzhugh said, and she told the outlet she expects the commission to review that system in the near future.
Former agency staffers told KQED the volunteer panel has at times overlooked evidence of wrongdoing. The outlet reported that state law requires districts to report certain educator departures involving misconduct allegations.
What District Reports and Public Records Show
California’s reporting rules require superintendents to report certain employment-status changes involving credential holders in credential-required positions within 30 days of a final employment action when misconduct allegations are involved or pending, according to the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing. The reporting rules are set out in California Code of Regulations section 80303. It also cautions that its public website does not contain complete information about suspended or revoked credentials, so the public lookup is not a complete record of those actions, according to the commission. A 2011 California State Auditor report offers historical context on the state’s educator-discipline system, though it did not assess the Committee of Credentials’ handling of Braff’s case. The report said that, according to Commission on Teacher Credentialing management, the Division of Professional Practices had about 12,600 unprocessed arrest and prosecution reports as of summer 2009, citing staffing and process problems.









