
A Washington County judge has rejected a proposed plea deal for one of three teenagers accused of trying to rob the Washington Food Mart last year, a robbery attempt that left a customer shot and seriously wounded. Judge Valarie Costanzo turned down the agreement for 19-year-old Christopher Ellis-Valperga, which would have resulted in a sentence of 5 to 10 years in jail.
Costanzo said she could not “in good conscience” accept a plea arrangement that would have sent Ellis-Valperga to jail for 5 to 10 years, according to Observer-Reporter. Ellis-Valperga is one of three teenagers accused of trying to rob the Washington Food Mart at 701 W. Chestnut St. on Nov. 30, 2025, and he faces charges of attempted homicide, aggravated assault, robbery and other offenses.
Customer Caught in the Crossfire
During the attempted robbery, 43-year-old customer Joelle Hepple was shot and seriously wounded, per the same account. The Herald-Standard reported in December 2025 that the three teens attempted to rob the store at gunpoint, and that a woman playing a video gambling machine inside apparently pulled out a handgun in self-defense before being Herald-Standard says was shot multiple times.
Hepple appeared in court Wednesday and told the judge that being shot twice caused the most indescribable pain. She said “everything about my life has changed” in the year since the shooting. Despite that, Hepple said she did not object to the proposed plea deal — a detail that makes the judge's decision to reject it all the more notable.
Co-Defendants Face Different Paths
The robbery case has already produced two other outcomes. Christian Zavier Patrene pleaded guilty in July to a felony count of conspiracy to commit robbery and was sentenced to serve 3 to 8 years in jail, the article notes. The Herald-Standard had previously reported that Patrene and Ellis-Valperga were ordered held without bond pending preliminary hearings tentatively scheduled for Dec. 17 at 2 p.m. in the weeks after the shooting.
The third person accused in the robbery was a 17-year-old at the time of the incident, and that case was handled through juvenile court. The November report on Ellis-Valperga's rejected plea identifies the juvenile co-defendant as Julian Ashby, who is serving a sentence at a juvenile detention facility — though an earlier article on Patrene's July guilty plea spelled the name Julian Asbury and said his case was adjudicated through juvenile court. The two accounts differ on the spelling, and it is not clear from either report which is correct.
What Comes Next
With the plea agreement rejected, Ellis-Valperga's case now moves back toward further proceedings. A status conference on the case has been scheduled for January, though the exact date was not specified in court records cited by the Observer-Reporter. It remains unclear what will happen next in the case or whether a new plea arrangement will be negotiated.









