Hampton Roads/ Real Estate & Development

York County Approves Sheetz Plan To Replace Vacant Williamsburg Motel On Bypass Road

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
York County Approves Sheetz Plan To Replace Vacant Williamsburg Motel On Bypass Road120 Bypass Rd. — Bypass Road Street Scene
Google Street View

The York County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously on Tuesday to approve plans for a new Sheetz convenience store and gas station at 120 Bypass Road in the Williamsburg area, clearing the way for demolition of the long-vacant Williamsburg Suites hotel. The approval ends a years-long saga involving building-code violations, cutoff utilities and repeated visits from the sheriff's office at the shuttered property.

A Troubled Motel Finally Comes Down

Board Chairman and District 1 representative Douglas Holroyd said the county had dealt with issues at the former Williamsburg Suites for years, telling fellow supervisors that the county had cut off electricity and water at the motel and that the sheriff's office had repeatedly entered the property, according to Williamsburg Yorktown Daily. The hotel's troubles were documented well before Tuesday's vote. In May 2025, York County officials said the property had been deemed “unsafe for occupancy,” as reported by The Virginian-Pilot.

According to that report, the county's Building Safety office had issued multiple violations concerning the condition of the hotel's elevator and stairs. County officials told the hotel the property was not to be occupied as of May 19, 2025, with only a one-day extension granted to the deadline. York County spokeswoman Kelli Tatum said at the time that long-term residential stays at the hotel were in violation of the zoning ordinance and were inconsistent with the property's certificate of occupancy.

What's Planned For The Site

The proposed Sheetz site sits between a vacant Hooters restaurant, a Cracker Barrel and a senior care facility, the station's report notes. The layout calls for eight fuel dispensers providing 16 fuel pumps, a convenience store with a drive-through area, two site entrances, parking, a dumpster and outdoor dining space.

Notably, the proposed site includes no electric vehicle charging stations at this time. Per the same account, Sheetz is aware of the board's updated zoning requirements for EV charging stations at fueling establishments. Attorney Emily Bittner of Miles & Stockbridge, who represented Sheetz before the board, said the company aims to provide a consistent customer experience for customers using gas or EV chargers, according to the outlet's report. Sheetz is separately launching an initiative to install more than 125 charging stations across seven states, per the same coverage.

Unanimous Support At Every Level

The York County Planning Commission had already approved the plan unanimously before it reached the Board of Supervisors, and county staff recommended approval of the proposal as well. No community members spoke either in favor of or against the plan during the board's consideration, the article notes.

Separately, application UP-1062-25 is for a 1.82-acre Redstone Properties LLC fuel-station project at four Route 17 addresses, not the Sheetz project on Bypass Road. It sought authorization for an automobile fuel dispensing establishment and convenience store under Section 24.1-306, Category 12, No. 2 of the York County Zoning Ordinance (York County, Virginia). Once built, the new store will mark Sheetz's third location in York County.