SFMTA to trim F-line schedule, citing operator shortage

F-line departing Castro for Fisherman's Wharf. | Photo: Steven Bracco/Hoodline
By Steven Bracco - Published on October 14, 2019.

In the coming year, MUNI riders will see schedule changes and service reductions on the Historic F-line.

MUNI's F-line street trolleys service Fisherman's Wharf along the Embarcadero and up Market Street terminating at 17th and Castro Streets. Many tourists, visitors and commuters use the trolley on a daily basis.

The clunky and whimsical ride is also frequently used by commuters as an alternative when the MUNI Subway experiences delays or shutdowns.

Passengers boarding at Jane Warner Plaza. | Photo: Steven Bracco/Hoodline

At the September 17th meeting of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA), which oversees MUNI, Director of Transit Julie Kirschbaum shared the news about the changes.

According to Kirschbaum, operator shortfall was the main factor for the changes. In 2020 SFMTA will release a new schedule that will better reflect current staffing level.

Currently, many scheduled F-line runs are "missed", meaning the schedule skips to the next departure time, due to a lack of qualified operators.

In order to adjust for the operator shortfall, SFMTA is "changing the schedule to reflect the number of part time operators we have, not just the number of part time operators we wish we had," Kirschbaum said.

Riders can expect to see the changes implemented in January or early February 2020.

Hoodline reached out to SFMTA spokesperson Erica Kato who echoed Kirschbaum's statement. Kato emphatically stated, "we are not cutting service."

Director of Transit Julie Kirschbaum. | Image: SFGovTV

On any given day MUNI has about 100 part time operators in the schedule. However, MUNI has only hired about 35 part time operators despite their recruiting efforts.

On an average day there are approximately 35 F-line runs, between 7-9 of which are missed, Kato explained.

Another 4 trolleys are used daily on SFMTA's E-line which runs between Fisherman's Wharf and Caltrain. Kato says no runs are typically missed on this line.

Kato was not able to provide Hoodline with a copy of the 2020 schedule.

Average F-line wait times. | Image: SFMTA

Kirschbaum explained the goal of the schedule modifications was to decrease missed runs.

"These are part of our ongoing approach to make incremental improvements to enhance our customer experience and improve our reliability," said Kirschbaum.

"As you know we're in a relativity resource constrained environment right now as result of the operator shortage," she added, explaining why there are no big additions to the schedule.

"We're constantly making shifts and refinements to make service better," she said.

"It will not be different than what we're delivering today, because unfortunately we just don't have enough operators trained on the Historic Fleet," she explained.

F-line turning around in Jane Warner Plaza. | Photo: Steven Bracco/Hoodline

As more MUNI operators are hired and trained, Kirschbaum said, "we'll be able to ratchet that back up."

"It'll be more stable because instead of having big gaps in service everything will be more smoothed out to match our actual resource levels," Kirschbaum said.

A new class of MUNI operators are currently training in the 9 week program. However, Kirschbaum said the class had to be cut from the typical 60 students to 30 due to a lack of qualified trainers.

In order to bring those numbers back up, Kirschbaum said the SFMTA is working on expanding the number of trainers.

Upon completion of the program, operators receive in-the-field training. "Once becoming a MUNI operator, employees are trained on what we call the rubber-tire fleet, which are our standard buses," Kato explained.

Additional training is required for MUNI employees to operate LRVs, Cable Cars and F-line trolleys.

Mayor London Breed at September operator's graduation. | London Breed/Twitter

SFMTA is presently recruiting more MUNI operators and is currently accepting applications.

Castro Merchants President Masood Samereie tells Hoodline they are currently monitoring the situation. "Castro Merchants continues to fully support full F-line schedules and service serving the Castro," said Samereie.

District 8 Supervisor Rafael Mandelman tells Hoodline he's currently in discussion with SFMTA about the new schedule. Mandelman is hopeful SFMTA will be able to stick to their promise of returning the schedule to full strength by summer.

"I will not be unhappy if it's fixed by summer," said Mandelman. "If that happens I will be pleased, I'll see that as win."

About 2 hours ago
San Francisco Embarcadero Financial District

‘Nash Bridges’ reboot movie shoot electrifying the Financial District

The old combination of Don Johnson and Cheech Marin is bringing new life to downtown San Francisco, in the form of gunshots and exploding cars for the “Nash Bridges” made-for-TV movie. Read More

About 2 hours ago
San Francisco

Bay Area restaurants will hold 'Dining for India' fundraiser to raise funds for India COVID-19 relief efforts

In light of India’s catastrophic second Covid-19 wave, ten local Indian eateries have partnered together to donate 50% of their sales on May 25 toward COVID-19 response efforts in India. Read More

About 2 hours ago
San Francisco

California is set to rescind mask mandates next month, but Bay Area counties likely to sort out their own new rules

With California less than a month away from its "full-reopening" on June 15, and after the Centers for Disease Control rescinded its mask mandate last week, it's still not clear what a mostly vaccinated, maskless, post-pandemic Bay Area will look like. Read More

May 14, 2021
San Francisco Embarcadero Fisherman's Wharf

Watch: The F-Line ‘Boat Tram’ returns with ribbon-cutting celebration

The Blackpool Boat Tram popularly known as “Boat Boi” returned to the rails Friday, in advance of this weekend’s reopening of Muni Metro service and stations. Read More