Cincinnati

Tensions Escalate in Cincinnati as Bengals Clash with Prosecutor Over Paycor Stadium Lease Negotiations

AI Assisted Icon
Published on May 22, 2025
Tensions Escalate in Cincinnati as Bengals Clash with Prosecutor Over Paycor Stadium Lease NegotiationsSource: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The lease negotiations for Cincinnati's Paycor Stadium between the Bengals and Hamilton County have hit a rough patch, with public criticisms and scathing letters between the team and the county prosecutor, Connie Pillich. The Bengals responded sharply to Pillich's comments, who criticized the pace of the lease discussions and suggested changes in the county's legal representation. According to FOX19 NOW, the Bengals' counsel, Emma Compton, accused Pillich of making "plainly false" public statements.

Hamilton County recently made a significant shift by ousting Tom Gabelman, a lawyer with nearly 30 years of involvement with the stadium negotiations and development, this move was accompanied by the hiring of attorneys from Dinsmore and Shohl as their new legal advisors, yet Pillich has asserted her desire to see the deal through without engaging in public sparring, stating, "I won't trade barbs with the Bengals. Let's just get the deal done," according to WLWT. The Bengals have questioned these recent changes, especially given the approaching June 30 deadline for notifying the county about extending the current lease.

In the midst of the controversy, further tensions were sparked by the county's employment of David Abrams, a consultant from Inner Circle Sports, due to past associations with the Cleveland Browns, the Bengals believe this connection may affect the negotiation process at hand even though, as Pillich clarified on WLW-AM (700), the specific member associated with the Browns has departed from Inner Circle Sports, and Abrams never worked with that team. Despite these disputes, the Bengals and Hamilton County have previously shown a collaborative spirit, as evidenced by a memorandum ratified at the end of April that aims to fund the first phase of improvements to the stadium and showcases a mutual desire for a lasting lease agreement, as reported by Sports Illustrated.

The Cincinnati Enquirer revealed that the Bengals have publicly committed to investing upward of $120 million this year and the next on stadium enhancements, already contributing $45 million within the prior few years, a substantial investment that the current discourse should not overshadow. With the county announcing its resolve to reach a deal beneficial for taxpayers and the football franchise, the stakes transcend the parameters of any sports deal, involving community resources and civic identity itself. With the statutory deadline for lease amendment or renewal looming, the Bengals have a decision to make, exercise the first of a potential five two-year options or seek greener pastures elsewhere should negotiations with Hamilton County hit an insurmountable gridlock.