Bay Area/ Oakland

Newark Police Uncover Mail Order Theft Scam, Hayward Suspect Charged with Identity Theft

AI Assisted Icon
Published on July 15, 2025
Newark Police Uncover Mail Order Theft Scam, Hayward Suspect Charged with Identity TheftSource: Google Street View

Residents of Newark are on alert after local police cracked down on a crafty mail-order theft scam operated by a Hayward individual. The arrest relieved a neighborhood that had been unknowingly wrapped up in an identity theft and fraud scheme. According to a Newark Police Department statement, wringing information and trust out of unsuspecting residents, the perpetrator found their fraudulent ventures cut short thanks to community vigilance.

On March 27, a resident reported a suspicious encounter with someone claiming to have a package misdelivered to the resident's address. Being approached at his home, the resident was duped into giving his phone number to the stranger, believing the person to be a good neighbor. The peculiar episode unfolded into a larger plot the next day when the resident received a package with his address but another name, and found unauthorized charges stacking up on his credit card.

These charges included high-ticket retail purchases worth thousands of dollars. Connecting the dots, the resident contacted Newark officers, who intervened just as the fraudster made contact to retrieve the misdelivered package. Newark Police's timely actions not only intercepted the delivery but also further unveiled the scope of the scam upon investigating the incident.

While sifting through the deceptive web, officers unearthed a brazen fraudulent purchase of a dental autoclave, priced at over $5,000, from a dental supply company. The crafty maneuver involved changing the shipping address to what was later confirmed to be the suspect’s home, using a phone number linked to a piercing studio in Hayward. Executing a search warrant at said studio, the stolen autoclave among other fraudulent orders were recovered, averting further financial detriment to the victims.

Ultimately, the suspect, identified as 24-year-old Tomasa "Tommy" Martinez Leon, found themselves in police custody on May 30. The Alameda County District Attorney’s Office has charged Martinez Leon with Felony Identity Theft and Felony Possession of Stolen Property, as detailed by the Newark Police Department. Martinez Leon's purported defense, claiming the equipment was purchased online at a discount, was part of the narrative laid out for the authorities.