The Trump administration has thrown its support behind Oklahoma in the contentious legal battle over the state's birth certificate law. In the Fowler v. Stitt case, currently before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, Oklahoma maintains a law that insists on listing a person's biological sex on birth certificates, barring amendments reflecting gender identity except under specific circumstances, such as clerical errors. The Department of Justice filed an amicus brief, siding with the state's policy and citing the necessity for keeping records precise and reserved spaces protected.
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond stands firm against changes he believes would amount to falsifying state documents. "This support from the U.S. Justice Department underscores the strength of Oklahoma's case," Drummond stated in a press release, expressing confidence in the law's legitimacy. The argument presented by Trump's DOJ and Drummond is grounded in the constitutional application of the law and the rational basis standard recently upheld by the Supreme Court in the United States v. Skrmetti decision.
According to the original brief, the policy's objectives are to ensure accuracy in vital records and reserve spaces meant for biological women and girls. The DOJ believes the rule serves a rational government interest and therefore should face less stringent legal scrutiny. The brief also references the Skrmetti ruling, suggesting it provides additional support for Oklahoma's legal stance in the present case.
The Tenth Circuit is re-evaluating the disputed Oklahoma law post-Skrmetti, which could set a significant precedent regarding how gender identity is legally recognized or disregarded in public record keeping. Drummond’s office has expressed its readiness to defend the statute at every stage, stressing the importance of official documentation accurately reflecting biological sex as a factual record.
For more detail on the Trump administration's involvement in the Oklahoma birth certificate controversy, visit the Oklahoma Attorney General's Newsroom.
.jpg){kind=link}