New York City

Accused in 2005 Long Island Fatal Crash Extradited from India, Faces Charges After 20 Years

AI Assisted Icon
Published on October 02, 2025
Accused in 2005 Long Island Fatal Crash Extradited from India, Faces Charges After 20 YearsSource: Nassau County DA

After two long decades, a family on Long Island has edged closer to closure with the extradition and charging of a man accused of causing a deadly 2005 crash. Ganesh Shenoy, 54, now faces charges for his alleged role in the high-speed accident that claimed the life of Philip Mastropolo, a 44-year-old father of two. ABC 7 New York reported that Shenoy was extradited from India last week, marking a significant turning point in a case that lingered in the hearts and minds of the Mastropolo family.

Nassau County prosecutors detailed how Mastropolo was on his way to work when Shenoy, allegedly traveling at nearly 80 mph, ran a red light and collided with his car; the force of the impact was so massive, it sent Mastropolo's vehicle hurtling 65 feet into the air, a tragic event that seems just as vivid and painful now as it did 20 years ago according to statements obtained by NBC New York. Despite having his passport and driver's license confiscated and then managing to flee to India, where he lived freely while opposing extradition, Shenoy is finally back on U.S. soil.

While speaking to ABC 7 New York, Nassau County District Attorney Anne Donnelly conveyed the significance of Shenoy’s return, saying, "We got him, and he's not getting away from us again." The Mastropolo family, who have endured two decades without their loved one, were reportedly comforted with the thought that justice might be imminent. They received the news of Shenoy's extradition with mixed emotions, the anticipation of justice after years of waiting clashing with the resurgence of the pain felt since that April morning in 2005 when they lost Philip.

The courtroom scene, as Shenoy faced charges, underscored the weight of the moment; Mastropolo’s now-adult children were present, described by one of the prosecutors as "elated," while Shenoy remained "expressionless" throughout, captured in a narrative by NBC New York. "The first thing the family said was, 'We never thought this day would come,'" DA Donnelly told the publication. Shenoy's not-guilty plea to second-degree manslaughter charges introduces yet another chapter in this enduring legal proceedings, a case whose resolution seemed for so long beyond reach, but now materializes before the Mastropolo family’s eyes.

If convicted, Shenoy could spend up to 15 years in prison, a prospect that brings a bittersweet sense of justice to those left to mourn Philip Mastropolo. The extradition has effectively stopped the clock on Shenoy's lengthy evasion of the U.S. justice system, offering the Mastropolo family a renewed hope for accountability and closure after 20 years of agonizing wait, as cited in statements obtained by NBC New York.