West Midtown’s sweet tooth is about to get some new competition. Pie Bar is planning a new cafe inside Westside Market on Ellsworth Industrial in West Midtown, with owner Dominie Garcia aiming for a May opening. The spot is set to sling sweet pies by the slice and by the whole, offer take-and-bake savory pies, pull espresso drinks, and let customers preorder any menu item for pickup. The new outpost is headed for 1530 Ellsworth Industrial Blvd NW.
Permit Filing And Timeline
The expansion surfaced in a recent permit filing, and Garcia confirmed the May target to What Now Atlanta. The report notes that the in-store selection will start out fairly tight, while the full menu is offered through preorder for pickup.
New Owner And Local Roots
Pie Bar launched in 2015 under founders Lauren and Cody Bolden and grew from farmers-market popups into brick-and-mortar locations in Woodstock, Marietta Square, and Kennesaw, according to Marietta.com. County records list Rustic Pie Bar LLC with DOMNIE GARCIA in a September 2025 registration, which confirms the ownership handoff late last year (Cobb County business listings).
What Pie Bar Will Serve
The menu at Pie Bar skews both classic and comfort-heavy. Sweet options include pies such as apple streusel and peanut-butter cream, while the savory take-and-bake lineup features items like rosemary chicken pot pie and shepherd's pie. According to Pie Bar's website, the existing shops sell slices and whole pies and list several savory, ready-to-bake choices that customers can order online.
Where It’s Going
The new cafe is slated for the Westside Market property at 1530 Ellsworth Industrial Blvd NW, a mixed retail and vendor space in West Midtown. The market’s listings highlight the address and a roster of vendors that help make the complex a visible retail hub for the neighborhood (Westside Market).
Neighborhood Context
West Midtown has been riding a wave of restaurant turnover in recent months, with local coverage tracking a series of closures that reshaped the area’s dining map (Atlanta News First). In a district that is still finding its new balance, a pie shop with grab-and-go options and preorder-friendly service may arrive to a built-in base of curious neighbors and daytime visitors.
Garcia told What Now Atlanta she is focused on organic growth for the Pie Bar brand. For opening-day details and menu updates, fans can keep tabs on Pie Bar via Instagram and its online ordering site: Pie Bar on Instagram and orderpiebar.com.
