Theresa Caputo, the reality TV medium best known as the star of Long Island Medium, is bringing her stage show to El Paso next month. Theresa Caputo LIVE! The Experience is set for Sunday, October 18, 2026, at 3 p.m. at the Plaza Theatre downtown.
The event promises audience interaction as its centerpiece, with promotional materials describing a show that “brings Theresa face-to-face with her fans as Spirit guides her through the audience,” according to the event listing on elpasolive.com. The performance is also listed among downtown El Paso's events for that Sunday, per downtownelpaso.com.
As reported by KTSM 9 News, tickets for the show are already on sale, starting at $80, and can be purchased through the Theresa Caputo live-events website or by calling the Plaza Theatre box office at 915-231-1100. KTSM 9 News also reports that a ticket purchase does not guarantee attendees a personal reading from Caputo during the performance.
What Audiences Can Expect Inside the Theatre
The show's description promises a mix of personal storytelling and comedic asides layered around Caputo's claimed ability to communicate with people who have died. The elpasolive.com listing describes the performance as unfolding “through personal life stories, candid humor, and intimate details about her gift to communicate with those who have passed.”
The event materials also frame the show as an emotional experience for grieving attendees, saying Caputo “delivers healing messages to her audience, reassuring them with the revelation that their deceased loved ones are still with them—just in a different way,” per the same elpasolive.com listing. Per KTSM 9 News, Caputo has said in a press release that the experience is about seeing something life-changing, and that she will deliver comforting messages to attendees.
Big Venue, No Bad Seats
For those worried about sightlines in a full theater, organizers say seat location won't be an issue. The listing notes that a full-stage video display will give everyone in the venue an up-close view of the show, regardless of where they're sitting.
The Plaza Theatre appearance adds El Paso to a run of stops for Caputo, whose national profile stretches well beyond her long-running TLC series. According to KTSM 9 News, she has appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, Live with Kelly and Mark, The Drew Barrymore Show, The Kelly Clarkson Show, The Today Show and Tamron Hall.
Beyond the TV Show
Caputo's reach extends into books and podcasting as well. KTSM 9 News reports she is the author of five books and helps guests deal with grief through her Ambie-nominated podcast.
For El Paso fans of the Long Island Medium franchise, the October 18 date offers a chance to see that persona in person rather than through a television screen. Doors, showtime and ticketing details are being handled through the Plaza Theatre box office, with the 3 p.m. start time confirmed by the Plaza Theatre's own event listing.
