
Thirty-six years after El Paso County Sheriff's Office Lieutenant Cecelia Benefield-Cipriani was found shot to death inside her Ivy-Wild home, Colorado Springs police say the case is still open and still being worked. Deputies discovered her body on the floor, still in uniform, after responding to a welfare check in November 1990. No one has ever been arrested.
A Welfare Check That Became a Homicide Scene
On November 18, 1990, El Paso County Sheriff's Office deputies went to check on Benefield-Cipriani at her home and instead found her dead from multiple gunshot wounds, according to FOX21 News Colorado. She was a lieutenant with the sheriff's office. Evidence at the scene indicated that several rooms of the home had been ransacked, the station reports.
Westword, reporting on the case separately, described the same ransacked scene with an unsettling detail: the house showed no sign of a forced break-in, and nothing had been taken, per Westword. That detail has long complicated efforts to explain what happened inside the home that day.
No Witnesses, No Explanation
Investigators at the time noted that several residential burglaries had recently occurred in the area, but no eyewitnesses were ever identified, per the Colorado Springs Police Department's account relayed through the FOX21 report. Neighbors reported nothing unusual around the house near the time of her death, the same reporting states.
Those gaps — no witnesses, no forced entry, nothing stolen — have left the case unresolved for over three decades. Colorado Springs police maintain that the investigation into the deputy's death continues 36 years later, and the station's report notes the case remains open.
Part of a Larger Backlog of Unsolved Cases
Benefield-Cipriani's case is one of roughly 122 cold cases the Colorado Springs Police Department is sitting on, a backlog that stretches back to 1953 and includes homicides, missing-person cases, and deaths of undetermined origin, according to KOAA. The department has leaned on social media to generate new leads, and CSPD Detective Tracey Thompson has said tips from the public have helped bring resolution to some of those cases, per the same report.
CSPD shares a summary of each cold case on the anniversary of the crime, KOAA notes, a practice aimed at keeping unsolved cases like Benefield-Cipriani's in front of the public. Her case is now assigned to the department's cold case unit, which continues to review it for applicability of new technology and look for new leads, according to the original FOX21 reporting that first detailed the welfare check and crime scene.
A separate case listing in the Colorado Cold Case Database gives the incident date as November 16, 1990, differing from the November 18 date reported by FOX21 and Westword. The discrepancy between the two accounts has not been resolved. What remains consistent across all reporting is that the case stays open until it's solved, and investigators are still asking anyone with information to come forward.









