
A 60-year-old man stood in an El Paso County courtroom Monday and pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and tampering with evidence in connection with the death of a 65-year-old woman found hidden inside a Colorado Springs motel room earlier this year. Timothy O'Brien's denial sets the stage for a case built on statements he allegedly gave investigators describing a sudden, violent outburst during what began as an overnight stay with Lauren Jensen-Green.
Not Guilty Plea Sets Next Court Date
O'Brien pleaded not guilty to his charges inside the courtroom on Monday, according to The Gazette. His next court hearing is set for a review on Feb. 8, 2027, the outlet reported, leaving the case to work through the legal process over the coming months before any trial proceedings move forward.
The case traces back to the morning of May 20, 2026, when Jensen-Green's body was found wedged between a bed and a nightstand inside the motel room, per the same Gazette account. Authorities believed the perpetrator had attempted to hide the body before leaving the scene, the outlet reported. Days later, O'Brien was arrested as a suspect, with a Colorado Springs Police Department caption cited in the report identifying May 25, 2026, as the date he was arrested and charged with first-degree murder.
Allegations Describe Motel Stay and Confrontation
According to The Gazette, O'Brien and Jensen-Green checked into a motel off South Nevada Avenue on one night in May and ended up staying for two nights. During that stay, the two allegedly used methamphetamine, and the outlet's report states that things escalated from there. The Gazette's account of O'Brien's arrest affidavit says he told investigators he took out a hammer after Jensen-Green began ranting about conspiracy theories.
In a recorded interview with a detective, O'Brien allegedly said, “I just freaking snapped. And I hit her a couple times, and she's obviously freaking out. And I kept going,” as reported by The Gazette. A separate June report from The Gazette added further detail, stating that O'Brien allegedly grabbed a hammer from his backpack, walked over to Jensen-Green while she was lying down, hit her in the head several times, and then smothered her with a pillow.
Case Has Moved Through Pretrial Hearings for Months
A September report from The Gazette said two Colorado Springs police detectives testified that O'Brien smoked methamphetamine with Jensen-Green before snapping at her for talking about conspiracy theories. That testimony came as the charges against him advanced through the court system ahead of Monday's arraignment.
A city release issued on May 26, 2026, said the El Paso County Coroner's Office would determine the official cause and manner of Jensen-Green's death, while noting that investigators were treating it as a homicide, according to the City of Colorado Springs. The specific details attributed to O'Brien's statements remain allegations reported in connection with the ongoing case rather than findings established at trial, and his not guilty plea means the matter will continue to play out in court before the February review hearing.









