
Alameda County will generally refrain from taking official positions on wars, genocides or other geopolitical matters that do not directly concern county governance or operations, after county supervisors narrowly approved a new neutrality policy this week. The resolution restricts formal statements, proclamations and sides-taking on international conflicts and foreign-policy disputes that do not directly concern county governance or operations, overriding a wave of public opposition from residents who showed up to object.
A Divided Board Draws the Line
Supervisors Nate Miley, David Haubert and Lena Tam voted in favor of the resolution, while Nikki Fortunato Bas and Elisa Márquez voted against it, according to The Oaklandside. Tam introduced the measure alongside Miley, and said afterward that it does not restrict individual board members or any residents from voicing their opinions about foreign affairs during public meetings. She added that the goal is to focus the board's limited time and resources on county issues rather than world events.
Andrea Weddle, the county's top attorney, said the policy is “not absolute” and does not preclude the board from taking up foreign issues that directly concern county operations, the outlet reported. That caveat leaves room for the county to act on matters with a direct operational tie, even as it steps back from broader symbolic statements on conflicts abroad.
Public Comment Ran Overwhelmingly Against It
The opposition at the meeting was close to unanimous. Nearly 20 public speakers addressed the policy, and every one of them spoke against it, per the same report. Fortunato Bas said she received 342 emails about the neutrality policy, and all but one opposed it.
Fortunato Bas argued that Alameda County is a welcoming place where many residents are refugees and immigrants, and said the Iran war had already driven up gas and diesel prices around the Bay Area while raising the cost of other essential goods, according to the Oaklandside article. Ranjeet Tate, a member of Jewish Voices for Peace and East Bay DSA, told the board that what happens around the world, and the effect of foreign policy, impacts local communities in a myriad of ways.
Haubert countered that the board is swamped with local issues that must take precedence, and said he would turn to national affairs once local problems were solved. Miley said it is difficult to decide which global issues the county should even address, and argued that government should stay focused on its own responsibilities.
A Reversal of Decades of County Activism
The vote marks a sharp break from the county's own history. In 1985, the board of supervisors voted to divest from apartheid South Africa, and in the 1990s supervisors divested county funds from companies doing business with Burma, according to the Oaklandside's reporting. As berkeleyside.org put it in its own coverage, the policy is a turn away from the county's history of engaging in world affairs.
That history extends into the present day. In 2025, the board approved an ethical investment policy barring the county from placing public funds with companies that enable human rights violations, but implementation of that broader divestment policy has since been suspended pending review. Haubert said it remains unclear whether the divestment policy is even achievable. The Mercury News reported that the board voted 4-1 on Oct. 3, 2025 to adopt that ethical investment policy while seeking an independent peer review that would delay its rollout for months.
Neighboring Cities Have Taken Starkly Different Paths
Alameda County's new hands-off stance stands in contrast to moves by nearby cities. Oakland approved a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza in 2023, while Berkeley later passed its own Gaza resolution that stopped short of calling for a ceasefire, the Oaklandside noted. Berkeleyside reported that Berkeley's resolution expressed empathy for people affected by the conflict and hope for peace in the region, without directly calling for an end to Israel's military campaign.
Richmond took a more pointed position, passing a resolution that expressed support for Palestinians and accused Israel of committing ethnic cleansing. CBS News reported that Richmond's city council voted 5-1 to approve that resolution, which also accused Israel of collective punishment. With its new policy, Alameda County has effectively ruled out joining its neighbors in staking out similar positions going forward.









