
Albany County Sheriff Craig D. Apple Sr. says he is weighing a plan to leave office months before his term ends in 2027, a move that would let the Democratic Party's endorsed sheriff candidate step into an acting role in the office before voters ever cast a ballot. Apple has served as sheriff since 2011 and already announced he would not seek a fifth term.
“I don't have 13 months in me,” Apple said in a text message Wednesday, according to the Times Union. The reported plan would likely involve appointing the Democratic Party's endorsed candidate, Gina Cocchiara, as undersheriff — a position left open since Michael Monteleone retired, with another member of the Sheriff's Office currently serving in an acting capacity. Apple described the idea as something he's considering, not a done deal, and the Times Union notes the plan has not been finalized.
The timing matters because acting control of the office ahead of the election would likely give the endorsed candidate a significant boost, per the same report. Cocchiara is running for the Democratic nomination for sheriff and has already picked up endorsements from Apple himself, along with Daniel P. McCoy and Joanne Cunningham. All three are scheduled to attend a fundraiser for Cocchiara Wednesday night, the outlet reports.
A Shift From Earlier Plans to Finish Out the Term
The idea of an early departure marks a change from what Apple indicated just months ago. Back in July, WNYT reported that Apple planned to serve through the end of his current term, even as he confirmed he would not run for a fifth term as sheriff. That July report also called the 2027 race the first time Albany County voters will pick a new sheriff since Apple took office in 2011. The Times Union's November report does not reconcile that earlier timeline with Apple's newer comments; both accounts are presented here because the dossier does not resolve which plan is current.
Cocchiara's path toward the office has been building since summer. She filed paperwork with the Board of Elections in July to form a campaign committee, the station's report on her campaign launch noted at the time. Her campaign manager, Libby Post, said Cocchiara would welcome the opportunity to step into an acting role, the Times Union reports.
A Second Name in the Mix, and a Party Process Still Ahead
Adam Hornick has expressed interest in the sheriff's position but has not formally declared a candidacy. Hornick said he is aware of the nomination process and electoral cycle and is weighing deadlines as he considers a run, according to the Times Union's reporting.
The Albany County Democratic Committee is expected to make its endorsements for county offices in February 2027, with those determinations coming through candidate interviews, questionnaires and internal committee recommendations before a full meeting of the party committee. A party endorsement can help a candidate gather nominating-petition signatures and raise money, the Times Union notes, as the 2027 general election approaches.
What the Law Says About Filling the Office
Any succession plan would unfold against a backdrop of state and county rules governing who runs the Sheriff's Office in a vacancy. Under state law, a sheriff's vacancy is to be filled by the governor with the advice and consent of the state Senate if it is in session, according to the excerpt published by the New York State Senate. A separate state-law excerpt states that the undersheriff is to execute the duties of sheriff until a new sheriff is elected or appointed and qualified, per the Senate's published text, though that excerpt is truncated and does not spell out every condition.
Albany County's own code addresses a related but distinct scenario: when a sheriff is absent or unable to perform the duties of the office, the sheriff designates in writing an order of succession among the undersheriff, deputy sheriffs and assistants to act in that capacity, according to Albany County's code. That acting sheriff holds the office's full powers and duties, the code states, while state law on vacancies in public office remains separately applicable. Neither the county code nor the state-law excerpts available fully reconcile how the reported resignation-and-appointment plan would proceed in practice, and nothing in the available record confirms that any succession arrangement has been legally settled.









