
A deeply divided federal appeals court ruled Friday that the U.S. House lacked a legal quorum when it passed a sweeping 2022 spending bill, a decision that now threatens protections for pregnant employees nationwide. The 9-8 ruling from the full Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals found that lawmakers improperly relied on pandemic-era proxy votes to pass the package, which included the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
The New Orleans-based court determined that proxy votes cannot be counted toward a quorum in the House, according to NBC News. The $1.7 trillion government funding bill passed the House in 2022 on a 225-201 vote, with 226 members casting their votes by proxy rather than appearing in person, per the outlet's reporting. Lawmakers had authorized remote and proxy voting as a COVID-19 safety precaution at the height of the pandemic.
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, tucked into that broader spending package, requires employers to provide accommodations to pregnant workers, including bathroom and water breaks, relief from heavy lifting, and time off for prenatal appointments. The Fifth Circuit's ruling left in place an injunction barring the Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant-worker provision against Texas, NBC News reports.
A Constitution Clause at the Center of the Fight
At the heart of the case is the Constitution's quorum clause, which, per the Constitution Annotated, Congress.gov, provides that a majority of each chamber of Congress constitutes a quorum to do business. The Fifth Circuit's majority wrote that the clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation, according to NBC News. Judge James Graves dissented, arguing the majority read a physical-presence requirement into the quorum clause that does not exist, the outlet's report states.
The Election Law Blog notes that the ruling specifically concluded that proxies may not be counted to establish a quorum when the House passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, the vehicle that carried the pregnant workers law. The court's judges also wrote that the Constitution's framers debated a quorum threshold at the constitutional convention and found that the pandemic-era proxy system conflicted with the standards those framers established, according to that reporting. Early legislatures, the judges wrote, never attempted to address quorum concerns through proxies.
Scope of the Ruling Disputed
Just how far the decision reaches is a matter of dispute among those tracking the case. The advocacy group A Better Balance says the ruling effectively invalidates the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, states the group says are home to roughly 20 million women. Bloomberg Law, however, reported that the decision applies only to Texas's own challenge to the law, attributing that view to Fifth Circuit Judge Cory Wilson. The two accounts differ on whether the practical fallout extends beyond Texas's borders.
The ruling caps a winding legal path. A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel held in August 2025 that the law was constitutionally enacted, but that decision was vacated after the full court agreed to rehear the case, Bloomberg Law reported. A Better Balance's account adds that in January 2026, the entire Fifth Circuit granted a petition for rehearing en banc and erased its earlier order upholding the law, setting up Friday's split ruling.
What Comes Next
The decision is expected to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, according to Bloomberg Law, though the record does not indicate that any party has yet filed such an appeal. The Election Law Blog cautioned that the Fifth Circuit's reasoning could threaten other laws passed using the same pandemic-era proxy procedures, including the Electoral Count Reform Act. Other federal courts had previously rejected challenges to proxy voting when it was first adopted, finding such cases foreclosed by the Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause, per Bloomberg Law's reporting.
A study estimated that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act reduced miscarriages by roughly 9.6 percent in studied or newly covered states, underscoring the stakes as the legal fight continues. The New York Times reported that legal experts said the ruling would effectively invalidate the law in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi and could produce ripple effects nationally, though as the conflicting accounts above show, the full scope of that impact remains contested.









