
A three-justice California appeals panel rejected challenges to the evidence against Travis Reid and Kenneth Peterson, leaving their first-degree murder convictions and life sentences without parole intact, MyNewsLA.com reported. Reid, 47, is from Maryland; Peterson, 48, is from North Carolina.
The convictions stem from the February 18, 2019, killings of Gary Davidson, 39, who owned and lived in the Porter Ranch home, Benny Lopez, 46, of Anaheim, and Jesus Perez, 34, of Perris. A jury convicted Reid and Peterson in December 2023, and they were sentenced in August 2024. Jurors also found true a multiple-murder special-circumstance allegation, made gun-use findings against both men and convicted them of attempted robbery of Davidson, according to MyNewsLA.com.
The appeals focused on separate gaps the defense said existed in the evidence. Reid’s attorney, Tony Garcia, argued that no witness saw Reid shoot anyone or placed him at the scene. Peterson’s attorney, Steven Giedzinski, contended that evidence linking Reid to Davidson did not establish a similar connection between Peterson and Davidson. The panel rejected both challenges, MyNewsLA reported.
At trial, then-Deputy District Attorney Victor Avila argued that Reid blamed Davidson after U.S. Postal Inspection Service inspectors intercepted a California cocaine shipment. Avila said Reid had lost more than $370,000 and urged jurors to hold both defendants accountable, according to MyNewsLA. Prosecutors also alleged that Reid and Peterson traveled across the country to rob and kill Davidson, the Press-Telegram reported during the trial.
The Los Angeles Police Department said Devonshire Division officers went to a residence in the 20300 block of Via Galileo on February 18, 2019, after a radio call reporting shots fired. The department’s account of the investigation says officers found three men shot inside.
What appellate caseload data shows
The Judicial Council of California says Courts of Appeal review the majority of appealable orders or judgments from superior courts, according to its court statistics report. That broad caseload measure does not show how often criminal convictions are affirmed in appeals challenging the sufficiency of the evidence.









