
A 26-year-old Aspen, Colorado man accused of causing a fatal 2021 crash in Norwalk is back in Connecticut custody after allegedly vanishing before his sentencing hearing last month. Peter R. Massey was extradited to Norwalk from Colorado on Thursday after allegedly failing to appear in court, and he now faces a new charge on top of the manslaughter case that has followed him for years.
According to WTNH, Massey is accused in a crash at the intersection of Westport Avenue and Dry Hill Road on Dec. 26, 2021, that resulted in fatal injuries to the driver of the other vehicle. As Newport Dispatch reported, the crash involved two vehicles — a westbound Geo on Westport Avenue and an eastbound Honda — and the Norwalk Police Department's crash reconstruction team determined that Massey, operator of the Honda, was at fault.
The man killed in the crash was identified as William Catugno, 62, according to The Hour's reporting on the arrest warrant. That same reporting detailed some of the evidence investigators cited in building the case, including toxicology and medical findings surrounding Massey at the time of the crash.
Toxicology Findings in Warrant
The Hour's report on the warrant states that a toxicology analysis of a blood sample taken hours after the crash showed 0 percent blood alcohol content but came back positive for THC, amphetamine, and methamphetamine. The same report noted that three passengers were in Massey's car at the time, two of them 17 years old, and that none of them were wearing seat belts.
Massey was originally arrested and charged with manslaughter in the second degree with a motor vehicle, two counts of operating a motor vehicle containing a passenger under 18 while under the influence, reckless driving, failure to yield the right of way when making a left turn, and failure to wear a seat belt, per Newport Dispatch's account of the case. He was held on a $150,000 bond at that time, according to the same report in The Hour.
Sentencing No-Show Triggered Nationwide Warrant
The case appeared to be heading toward resolution this fall until Massey allegedly failed to appear for a scheduled sentencing hearing on Oct. 26 at Stamford Superior Court. That no-show prompted the State's Attorney's Office at Stamford Superior Court to issue a nationwide extraditable arrest warrant for Massey, as detailed by Newport Dispatch.
The Edgewood Police Department in Colorado took Massey into custody on Nov. 2, according to the same WTNH report cited earlier. Norwalk Police Department detectives then extradited him back to Norwalk, and he was charged with failure to appear in the first degree. WTNH reported that his bond was set at $750,000 on the new charge — five times the amount set in the original case years earlier.
Massey appeared in court in Norwalk on Friday, Nov. 20, 2026.









