Philadelphia/ Real Estate & Development

Atlantic City's Carlton Apartments Sells for $6M, Ending 40-Year Family Hold

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 22, 2026
Atlantic City's Carlton Apartments Sells for $6M, Ending 40-Year Family HoldCarlton Apartments — Site of $6M Sale and Renovations
Google Street View

A 10-story apartment tower that has anchored a stretch of Pacific Avenue in Atlantic City since 1927 has new ownership for the first time in more than 40 years. The Carlton Apartments at 1329 Pacific Ave., an 82-unit building with two ground-floor retail spaces, sold for $6 million to Eli Nichtberger of Blockstone Capital, with the deal closing in November 2026.

The sale price works out to roughly $73,000 per unit and reflects a 5.8 percent capitalization rate, according to Real Estate NJ, which reported that the property had been under the same ownership for more than 40 years prior to the sale. The building includes 30 studio apartments, 40 one-bedroom units and 12 two-bedroom units, along with two ground-floor retail spaces occupied by Carlton Laundromat and AC Island Pizza. Some residents have lived in the building for 20 or more years, per Nichtberger.

What's Changing Inside the 1927 Tower

Nichtberger's plans for the Carlton, as detailed by NJ.com, call for renovations to the lobby and common areas, new carpeting, updated paint finishes and energy-efficient LED lighting throughout the building. The building is also set to receive significant exterior masonry and façade work along with a building-wide security monitoring system, and the modernization is described as aiming to preserve the building's 1920s character.

Nichtberger said the improvements are part of a broader commitment to enhancing residents' living experience and investing in the property's long-term future. He also said the purchase reflects confidence in Atlantic City and a commitment to its long-term future.

The Deal Behind the Deal

Hudson Atlantic Realty handled the transaction, with Vice President Dante Fusaro leading the deal and firm president Adam Zweibel assisting. Per Hudson Atlantic Realty, the sale also required a compliance process involving the Casino Reinvestment Development Authority before it could close.

Part of a Broader Housing Push

The Carlton sale lands amid a wider wave of reinvestment in Atlantic City's aging housing stock. Just days earlier, a groundbreaking ceremony marked the start of a $22.5 million redevelopment turning the long-vacant Schwehm Building, a 1920s Renaissance Revival landmark on New York Avenue, into loft-style apartments, according to The Press of Atlantic City. Odin Properties CEO Philip Balderston said that project addresses a gap in the market, noting that “there's really nobody doing rental apartments for folks that live and work here.”

Elsewhere in the city, WinnDevelopment has begun a $33 million renovation of Garden Court Apartments, a 177-unit complex spread across 20 buildings, according to Multifamily Affordable Housing. That project's scope includes upgraded kitchens, bathrooms and flooring along with new windows, siding, balconies and roofs, and the units are set to remain affordable to renters earning no more than 80 percent of area median income for the next 45 years. Completion of the Garden Court work is slated for fall 2027.

Taken together, the Carlton sale, the Schwehm Building groundbreaking and the Garden Court overhaul point to a city grappling with how to renew its oldest residential buildings while keeping them livable for longtime tenants.