
The Michigan Court of Appeals has upheld the convictions of a man sentenced to decades in prison for raping a woman at an Auburn Hills hotel, but it is sending the case back to Oakland County Circuit Court with an unusual demand: the judge must explain why he stacked the sentences on top of each other.
In an unpublished opinion issued Thursday, the appeals court affirmed Joel Delavara's convictions and rejected a string of additional claims he raised on appeal, according to The Oakland Press. But the court found that the trial judge never gave a specific rationale for ordering Delavara's sentences to run consecutively rather than at the same time, which the appellate panel said made meaningful appellate review impossible. The case has now been remanded so the trial court can state its reasoning on the record.
What Happened at the Hotel
Delavara, now 38 and living in Yuma, Arizona, met the victim at a work-related convention held at the hotel, per the same report. The two had dinner and drinks together at a restaurant and bar before returning to the hotel, and the woman later went to her own room alone, believing she was intoxicated. A hotel employee then gave Delavara a key to her room, and he entered and sexually assaulted her, the Oakland Press account states. At trial in 2025, the victim testified she had never given anyone permission to enter her room.
A jury convicted Delavara on March 14, 2025, of the crimes connected to the August 14, 2024 attack at the Sonesta Select Detroit in Auburn Hills, according to the Daily Tribune. That outlet reported Delavara obtained the victim's room key from a front desk employee of the hotel before the assault.
A Sentence That Stretches Decades
At sentencing, Delavara was ordered to serve 15 to 40 years in prison for first-degree criminal sexual conduct, the Daily Tribune reported. He also received a consecutive sentence of 85 months to 25 years for first-degree home invasion, meaning that sentence must be served only after the first is completed. A separate sentence of 71 months to 15 years for second-degree criminal sexual conduct was ordered to run concurrently with the first-degree CSC sentence, according to the Oakland Press's earlier coverage of the sentencing.
Delavara is currently incarcerated at the Ernest C. Brooks Correctional Facility in Muskegon. The Oakland Press reported he was 37 years old at the time of his 2025 sentencing, while the news organization's more recent reporting on the appellate decision lists his age as 38.
What Delavara Argued on Appeal
In challenging his sentence, Delavara argued the evidence supporting his home invasion conviction was insufficient and claimed the trial court did not properly answer a jury question about alcohol's effect on consent. He also contended that his decision not to give a statement improperly affected his sentence, and argued the court ignored his rehabilitation potential and lack of a prior criminal record. The Michigan Court of Appeals rejected each of those additional claims.
Where the court sided with Delavara was narrower: it ruled only that the trial court must state on the record its specific reasons for imposing consecutive sentences, so that an appeals court can actually evaluate whether that decision was justified. Under Michigan law, a judgment committing someone to the Department of Corrections must specify whether a sentence runs consecutively or concurrently with any other sentence, according to Michigan Legislature, MCL 769.1h. The remand does not disturb Delavara's convictions or the length of any individual sentence — it simply requires the judge to put his reasoning on paper.









