Kern County/ Bakersfield/ Politics & Govt

Bakersfield Bakery Settles Lawsuit Over Refusal to Sell Lesbian Couple a Wedding Cake

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Bakersfield Bakery Settles Lawsuit Over Refusal to Sell Lesbian Couple a Wedding CakeBakery Wedding Cake
David Holifield / Unsplash

A Bakersfield bakery that refused to sell a wedding cake to a lesbian couple has settled a long-running lawsuit with the state, agreeing to pay $12,000 in damages and fees and to overhaul how it treats customers going forward. Tastries reached the settlement with the California Civil Rights Department, closing out a legal fight that stretched from a local courtroom all the way to the steps of the U.S. Supreme Court.

The case traces back to a dispute between Tastries and Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio, a couple who wanted a generic white wedding cake for their celebration, according to 23ABC News Bakersfield. Tastries refused to sell them the cake, and according to the state, the bakery had a policy against selling cakes for celebrations of same-sex unions. The couple filed a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department, which later sued the bakery in 2018.

The timeline of exactly when the refusal took place is murky. KGET 17 News reports that Tastries owner Cathy Miller refused to bake the cake in 2017 after learning the couple's sexual orientation, while Bakersfield.com describes the couple as having been denied the cake in 2018. Either way, what followed was a years-long legal battle that worked its way through multiple levels of California's court system.

From a Kern County Win to an Appellate Reversal

A trial court initially ruled in Tastries' favor in 2022, siding with the bakery in the dispute. But an appellate court reversed course in 2025, siding with the state and ruling that Tastries' refusal to sell the wedding cake amounted to intentional discrimination, per KGET's reporting.

Both the California Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to take up the case after the appellate ruling, leaving the appeals court decision in place. That left Tastries facing the settlement terms it has now agreed to.

What the Settlement Requires Going Forward

Under the agreement, Tastries has agreed to provide non-customized products, including cakes, to all customers regardless of sexual orientation or other protected characteristics. The bakery also agreed to change its sales policies and take steps aimed at preventing future discrimination.

Beyond the $12,000 payment, the settlement's terms, outlined by the same station's report, require Tastries to participate in annual civil rights training provided by the Civil Rights Department, post notices at the business about state civil rights protections, notify the department of any future discrimination complaints, and submit annual compliance reports. The settlement and the underlying dispute are tied to the bakery's location in Bakersfield.

The case centers on California's Unruh Civil Rights Act, which requires businesses to provide full and equal access to goods and services regardless of protected characteristics, including sexual orientation. The years-long path from a local court ruling to an appellate reversal, and the subsequent refusal of both state and federal high courts to intervene, underscores how firmly the case ultimately came down on the side of the Civil Rights Department.