Capital Region/ Food & Drinks

Baldwinsville Pizza Man Alum Trades Pies for Bagels in New Village Shop

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Baldwinsville Pizza Man Alum Trades Pies for Bagels in New Village ShopPizza Man Pub — Approximate Family Pizzeria Location
Google Street View

A bagel shop is coming to downtown Baldwinsville, and it's being built by a guy who spent years slinging pizza just down the street. Luke and Rebecca Delia are opening Village Bagel Co. at 24 E. Genesee St., expected to debut in March or April 2027, in a storefront that has sat empty for roughly two years.

The Delias will take over the former Subway space next to Colonial Laundromat, near the village's library and post office, according to syracuse.com. The planned menu includes bagels, homemade cream cheeses, breakfast and lunch sandwiches, soups and coffee, with about six specialty breakfast bagel sandwiches and a similar number of lunch options, plus seasonal offerings.

One detail is still up in the air: whether the bagels themselves will be made in-house or brought in as dough from New York City. That decision, per the report, hasn't been made yet as the couple works out recipes and logistics ahead of opening.

Using New York-sourced product would not be unprecedented in the Syracuse-area bagel trade. DeWitt Bagel Company, a family-owned shop listed by Visit Syracuse, says it receives bagels and bialys shipped from New York City, then thaws and bakes them locally. That is not the same as the Delias’ still-undecided idea of receiving dough, but it shows a regional shop can build its offering around NYC-sourced bagels rather than making them entirely from scratch on site.

A Short Walk From the Old Family Pizzeria

Village Bagel Co. will sit about two-tenths of a mile from Pizza Man Pub, the Oswego Street restaurant Luke Delia's father opened in 1983, three years before Luke was born. Luke ran the pizzeria alongside his brother Jimmy and their father for years before Jimmy eventually bought out his share.

Pizza Man’s history also gives the new shop a distinctly local food-business lineage: the restaurant says it began in June 1983 as a family business, making its dough and sauce on site each day, then added a pub in December 2007. That long-running operation remains at 50 Oswego St., within a short walk of the proposed bagel shop. The move is a change of format for Delia, but not a break from a family-run Baldwinsville food business, according to the restaurant’s history.

Luke stepped away from Pizza Man to spend more nights, weekends and holidays with his family. His children are 5 and 7 years old, and the new bagel shop offers him a path back into the food business on a schedule he says fits better with family life.

The food business, Luke said, has been his life, and he loves it. He also said Village Bagel fills a need he and Rebecca see in Baldwinsville's current lineup of restaurants.

A Frequent Bagel Run Turned Business Plan

Luke and Rebecca have said their hometown needs a bagel shop, and they should know: the couple has been traveling to other communities two or three times a month just to get decent bagels. That recurring road trip appears to be part of what pushed them toward opening their own place instead.

The Delias announced Village Bagel on Facebook the weekend before the report published, and Luke described the response as overwhelming. Still, the couple isn't rushing the timeline. Luke said they want to get everything right before launch, and that they plan to create a cozy, welcoming space for the Baldwinsville community to gather over coffee and bagels once the doors open.

Any opening will also fall under ordinary state food-safety oversight: New York’s Sanitary Code Part 14 covers sit-down and takeout food-service establishments, with permits issued by the local health department. Onondaga County’s Food Protection office lists a food-service establishment permit application and restaurant inspections among its services. For a shop planning bagels, sandwiches, soups and coffee, county permitting is part of the regulatory backdrop to the couple’s build-out and launch planning.