Lowcountry/ Crime & Emergencies

Beaufort Judge Clears Driver In Trask Parkway Cyclist Death Trial

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Beaufort Judge Clears Driver In Trask Parkway Cyclist Death TrialSource: Google Street View

A Beaufort County magistrate has ruled in favor of the driver accused of hitting and killing a bicyclist on Trask Parkway, cutting the trial short before jurors ever got to decide the case. Patricia D. Lopez Mendez had pleaded not guilty to a charge of driving too fast for conditions in connection with the July 17, 2026, crash that killed 31-year-old Christopher Alan James.

The trial, which wrapped up on November 12, ended when Beaufort County Magistrate Nancy D. Sadler granted a directed verdict in Lopez Mendez's favor on the traffic charge, according to The Island News. Sadler found there was insufficient evidence to send the charge to the jury, a decision that came after defense attorney Christopher Dore moved for a directed verdict once the state rested its case.

James, who lived in Wrens, Georgia, was riding north on U.S. 21 — also known as Trask Parkway — near Stroban Road at about 9:35 a.m. when he was struck, according to the outlet's earlier reporting on the family's questions about the investigation. He was pulling an orange cargo trailer at the time. The South Carolina Highway Patrol concluded a Toyota Highlander struck James from behind near the right edge of the travel lane, and he died at the scene.

What Happened Inside the Courtroom

Lopez Mendez, who lives in Beaufort, was identified as the driver through a combination of evidence, prosecutors argued. Trooper Cesar A. Cuata Hernandez found her driver's license inside the Highlander, and she later confirmed at Beaufort Memorial Hospital that the license was hers. The state argued that witness testimony, the license, and the hospital interview together established that Lopez Mendez had been behind the wheel.

Dore countered that the exchange at the hospital established Lopez Mendez's identity but did not prove she was actually driving. Sandler herself said she believed the trooper had identified Lopez Mendez in his testimony, but she also noted that some photos and video discussed during the trial had not been formally admitted into evidence.

Witness Linda Dickson testified that she believed her husband was driving the speed limit as their vehicle approached the Highlander, and that she saw debris fly before the SUV pulled over. The defense argued Dickson's account suggested the SUV was traveling below the posted limit, while Sandler noted that Dickson's testimony did not actually explain how the collision happened.

Arguments Over Speed and Evidence

Prosecutors pointed to damage on the front of the SUV and argued that James's presence on a straight stretch of highway required Lopez Mendez to slow down. They leaned on the principle that South Carolina law requires drivers to travel at a reasonable and prudent speed for conditions, even when within the posted limit. The relevant statute states that a person shall not drive faster than is reasonable and prudent given the actual and potential hazards present, according to South Carolina Code Section 56-5-1520.

The defense argued that the collision alone did not establish that Lopez Mendez was driving too fast for conditions, and maintained that Dickson's account of her own husband's speed undercut the state's theory. The posted speed limit on that stretch of Trask Parkway is 60 mph, and the Highway Patrol crash report had estimated the Highlander was traveling at that same speed.

Sandler ultimately said there had to be a link between the evidence presented and the alleged violation, and found that link missing. She excused the jury after granting the defense motion, ending the trial on the traffic charge without a verdict from jurors.

What Family and Earlier Investigation Records Showed

Dore called the crash a tragedy. Anthony Dore told Shirley James, Christopher's mother, that he was very sorry for her loss; Christopher Dore said he had recently lost a family member in a car crash himself. Shirley James has said she never wanted Lopez Mendez jailed, but that she wanted a consequence for the crash that killed her son and that there needs to be some kind of accountability.

Earlier reporting from the same outlet detailed how Shirley James, along with Michael James and Marc James, reviewed police records, photographs, and dashcam footage in October 2026. That review found the crash report recorded no improper action by Christopher James, and the family has questioned how investigators ruled out impairment, since a trooper reported no outward signs of impairment and the records reviewed contained no completed field sobriety test or result, per the earlier Island News account. The family said the crash investigation resulted in three traffic citations.

Court records at the time of that earlier reporting showed three separate traffic cases pending against Lopez Mendez in Beaufort Magistrate Court, with no disposition entered. James had traveled by bicycle with camping gear packed into his trailer and had returned to Beaufort County to watch the Fourth of July fireworks before the crash; he had sent his mother a text saying he was living his best life.