
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier's office is examining complaints against Saint Stephen's Episcopal School in Bradenton after the office said the private religious school expelled several students following objections to classroom reading material, then kept their tuition and refused to hand over transcripts. At least two families appear to be affected, though the students involved have not been publicly identified.
The review centers on claims that the school assigned books some parents found objectionable after being told the curriculum would be free of LGBTQ-related instructional material, according to the Office of Parental Rights, as reported by mysuncoast.com. The office said the assigned titles included “The Poet X” by Elizabeth Acevedo, “Girl” and “Annie John” by Jamaica Kincaid, and “Answers in the Pages” by David Levithan. Parents complained about what they described as sexually suggestive material in their classrooms.
Families Allege Tuition Kept, Transcripts Withheld
Beyond the dispute over the books themselves, the attorney general's office alleges the school kept tuition money after expelling the students and withheld their academic transcripts, FOX 13 Tampa Bay reports. Uthmeier's office is examining whether the students were expelled without receiving a refund. The attorney general's office has demanded that the school preserve records, stop any collection efforts against the affected families, and make those families whole, per the same outlet's reporting.
Uthmeier said the allegations raise concerns under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, though the attorney general's office has not called this a formal investigation. Florida's Attorney General Consumer Protection Division serves as the civil enforcement authority for violations of that act. The office has demanded a response from the school by Nov. 30, according to the Herald-Tribune.
School Says It Will Cooperate
Saint Stephen's Episcopal School said in a statement that it would cooperate fully with the attorney general's office and that it is confident it acted ethically and in accordance with its educational values, policies, and Florida law, FOX 13 Tampa Bay reported.
The Herald-Tribune frames the Bradenton case as Uthmeier's latest entry into a Florida schools matter, noting the attorney general has also turned his attention to a case involving Sarasota's Pine View School. The outlet also detailed that separate matter, including the teacher, disciplinary actions, and events at issue.
Part of a Broader Pattern in Florida Schools
A Bradenton Herald report on an Orlando Sentinel investigation found that 156 Florida schools received more than $129 million from the state's scholarship programs in a single year. That same Bradenton Herald report recalled a 2020 finding that Bradenton Christian School had been identified among schools that refused admission to students based on sexual orientation or gender identity, noting that more than 180 students had used a state voucher at that school the previous year, totaling more than $1.1 million in scholarships.
No official court filing or final determination from the attorney general's office was part of the record reviewed for this story, and Uthmeier has been careful to characterize the current review as an examination of complaints rather than a formal investigation. Whether the school responds by the Nov. 30 deadline, and what the attorney general's office ultimately concludes, remains to be seen.









