Boston/ Food & Drinks

Bridgewater Chocolate Opens First Shop Outside Connecticut in Wellesley Square

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Bridgewater Chocolate Opens First Shop Outside Connecticut in Wellesley SquareSource: Tetiana Bykovets / Unsplash

A Connecticut chocolate maker known for its toffees and turtle candies has set up shop in Wellesley Square, taking over the longtime home of the Wellesley Toy Shop at 59 Central St. Bridgewater Chocolate's new storefront marks the company's fifth retail location overall and its first permanent shop outside Connecticut, bringing hand-tied gift boxes and chocolate-covered treats to a new corner of Massachusetts just as the holiday shopping season ramps up.

The opening was detailed by The Swellesley Report, which noted that all of Bridgewater's chocolate is still made at the company's factory in Brookfield, Connecticut, where the Wellesley shop's inventory and any online orders are shipped from directly. The Wellesley location joins four other Bridgewater retail shops in Connecticut, according to the same report.

Store manager Vanessa Brandt said the company wanted to test different Boston-area neighborhoods before settling on a permanent spot, according to the Swellesley Report's account. Bridgewater had previously run pop-up shops on Newbury Street and at The Street in Chestnut Hill to see which location suited the brand best, the report said. Brandt said Wellesley stood out for its small independent businesses and welcoming community.

From a Basement in Bridgewater to Wellesley Square

Bridgewater Chocolate's roots trace back to a village store in Bridgewater, Connecticut, where in 1994 owner Peter May hired Swedish chef Erik Landegren, per the Swellesley Report's telling. Landegren began experimenting with chocolate in the store's basement, and the company's first confections emerged from that space in 1995. Today the brand describes its specialty as classic American candies made with European techniques and recipes, carrying the slogan “Making an Impression.”

The company's best sellers remain its toffees and what it calls “Tortles” — clusters of nuts, caramel and chocolate modeled on the classic turtle candy. Brandt described the chocolate-making process using an enrober, a machine that coats fillings with melted chocolate, as “almost like a chocolate waterfall,” per the Swellesley Report. Her own favorite, she said, is the smooth peanut butter patty.

What's on the Shelves, and What It Costs

Bridgewater is perhaps best known for its signature assortment sold in hinged gift boxes, which at the Wellesley shop come in a half-pound box of 10 pieces for $47.95, a one-pound box of 19 pieces for $74.95, and a two-pound box of 38 pieces for $131.95. Customers can also build their own box from the by-the-piece case, which runs $63.95 a pound, and staff hand-tie every bow sold in the store.

The Wellesley shop stocks mostly the company's best sellers rather than its full catalog, while Bridgewater's website offers a wider selection, with online orders shipping directly from the Brookfield factory. The company also offers less expensive options alongside its premium boxed assortments, and its seasonal lineup changes with every holiday. Right now the shelves hold chocolate turkeys for Thanksgiving, and the shop also carries Hanukkah items; Christmas will bring cherry-red boxes and party favors.

Business Picks Up as the Holidays Approach

Business at the new shop has been picking up as Thanksgiving approaches, the Swellesley Report's account noted. Bridgewater recently began advertising in the area, though the company relies mostly on TV commercials and events to spread the word rather than traditional local marketing. Brandt said she hopes the Wellesley shop becomes a fixture among the town's small businesses.

The Central Street corridor where the shop landed draws significant pedestrian traffic, with the shopping district seeing more than 356,000 annual visitors, according to Placer.ai data cited by Linear Retail. Bridgewater's push into Massachusetts follows an earlier Boston-area venture: a Chestnut Hill shop at 33 Boylston St. that opened in August 2024 and was, at the time, described by The Boston Globe as the company's only Massachusetts location. That shop's boxed chocolates ranged from $40.95 for 10 pieces up to $265 for a five-pound, 108-piece box, the Globe reported.