Charlotte/ Real Estate & Development

Brunswick County Tables 1,140-Home Ibis Bay Plan Over Flood, School Fears

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Brunswick County Tables 1,140-Home Ibis Bay Plan Over Flood, School FearsNorth Carolina Housing Development
Gene Gallin / Unsplash

Brunswick County commissioners hit pause this week on a sprawling 1,140-home development proposed near Holden Beach Road and Shell Point Road in the Supply area, after a technical review panel raised red flags over flood-prone lots, schools that could exceed capacity and strained emergency services. The board voted to table the Ibis Bay proposal rather than approve or deny it outright, pushing the matter to a public hearing scheduled for January 19, 2027.

Commissioner Pat Sykes made the motion to table the project, which the board approved, as reported by the Charlotte Observer. Sykes said she was still waiting on additional project documents and wanted to meet with the county attorney to better understand the property's investment rights before moving forward. The delay means a project that has been on the books for about 22 years will sit in limbo for at least two more months.

The proposal comes from engineering firm Thomas & Hutton, which filed a revised plan expanding the project footprint to roughly 621.5 acres under property owner Stars & Stripes 2B LLC. That revision trims the unit count from the 1,221 homes approved in September 2004 down to 1,140, according to the same report, while also increasing open space and removing residential lots that previously sat in wetlands. A county notice describes the overall density at 1.83 dwelling units per acre on the 621.50-acre tract.

Flood Zone Lots Draw Objections

County staffer John Shirk did not recommend approval of the plan as submitted, citing lots placed in the AE flood zone along Shallotte Creek and a floodway that wasn't clearly shown on the application, per the Charlotte Observer's reporting. Shirk said filling in the area for development would impact watershed storage, and if the plan isn't modified, the contractor would need to use acceptable modeling to replace that lost storage capacity.

The plan's main road entry from Holden Beach Road includes a floodway crossing that requires a contractor study demonstrating no increase in base flood elevation before it can move forward, the outlet reported. Shirk reportedly said the project would be denied outright if that study can't prove there's no rise in base flood elevation at the crossing. The proposal may also constitute an alteration of a watercourse, which would need sign-off from other agencies before the county could approve it. Separately, FEMA guidance describes a general requirement that any project located in a floodway be reviewed to determine whether it would increase flood heights, with an engineering analysis required before a permit is issued.

Despite those concerns, Brunswick County planning staff recommended approval, finding the plan consistent with the county's Unified Development Ordinance standards, according to the Charlotte Observer. The technical review committee, however, identified a broader set of infrastructure and environmental issues that factored into the board's decision to table rather than vote.

School Capacity and Ambulance Concerns

School officials believe several nearby schools could exceed capacity before 2031, the Charlotte Observer reported, a concern that lines up with countywide enrollment projections. A 2025-2026 forecast found Brunswick County elementary schools are estimated to exceed 100% of districtwide aggregate capacity by the 2028-2029 school year, with high schools following in 2030-2031 and middle schools in 2035-2036, according to Port City Daily. Brunswick County Schools has pointed to rapid development across the county as the reason behind its newly approved $349.6 million school bond, which passed with 54.95% voter support earlier this month. Because North Carolina doesn't allow school impact fees, the outlet noted, districts have fewer tools to make new developments help cover the cost of added enrollment.

Emergency services face a similar squeeze. Brunswick County EMS estimated the development would generate hundreds of service calls, and county official Lyle Johnston said that at full buildout, Ibis Bay would add more than 2,600 permanent residents and roughly 411 annual EMS incidents, per the Charlotte Observer. Johnston said that projected demand could strain unit availability in the Supply and Shallotte response areas even with two nearby 24-hour response units already in place. Those worries echo countywide trends documented in 2021, when the Brunswick County population was just under 143,000 after growing by more than 35,000 people over the preceding decade, and EMS crews were averaging 9.5 minutes to respond across nearly 89,000 calls between 2017 and 2021, according to the Wilmington StarNews.

Traffic and Neighbors Weigh In

A traffic impact analysis reviewed by the North Carolina Department of Transportation calls for additional turn lanes, new signalized intersections and other roadway improvements during construction, the Charlotte Observer reported. Once finished, the development could generate about 9,500 daily vehicle trips.

Technical review committee members raised concerns that stretched beyond traffic, pointing to effects on schools, emergency services and flood-prone areas as central to their hesitation, per the Charlotte Observer. The current plan would preserve more than one-third of the site as open space, including over 100 acres of wetlands near the Shallotte Creek corridor, according to that report. A newsletter from Citizens for Better Brunswick separately noted the county's index recorded 67 acres of open space under the older, denser plan.

The project's long history adds another layer to the debate. Ibis Bay was first approved in May 2004 for 1,120 units on 560.8 acres before being revised that September to 1,221 units on 612.4 acres, according to Citizens for Better Brunswick. The newsletter also reported that 40 lots were recorded in 2007, which a county staff member described to the author as the point that vested the project, and that no construction has taken place since. The Charlotte Observer's reporting likewise notes there has been no construction on the site to date. Commissioners are now expected to take the matter back up at the January 19 public hearing, when the board will weigh those competing recommendations once more.