Treasure Valley/ Politics & Govt

Caldwell Mayor Picks Top Police Chief Pick, Keeps Name Under Wraps

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Caldwell Mayor Picks Top Police Chief Pick, Keeps Name Under WrapsCaldwell Police Department — Interim Police Chief Selection
Google Street View

Caldwell Mayor Eric Phillips has settled on one finalist to become the city's next police chief, narrowing a monthslong search down to a single name that he is not yet ready to reveal. The finalist still has to clear a background investigation, a polygraph exam and a physical fitness test before coming before the Caldwell City Council for a final interview.

Phillips interviewed both of the search's top two finalists individually before identifying what he called a clear first choice, according to Idaho News. He then directed the city's Human Resources Director to advance that candidate through the remaining stages of the hiring process, per the same report. The mayor praised the finalist's professional background, local experience, training and vision, and said the candidate's leadership and knowledge of Canyon County stood out during the interview process.

“I subsequently directed our Human Resources Director to advance that individual through the remaining stages,” Phillips said, according to the outlet's reporting. He added that he would not rush the process or compromise its integrity, and said every candidate must successfully complete the entire selection process regardless of his personal pick.

How the Field Narrowed to One

The recruitment closed Oct. 1 with 17 applicants, the station's report states, though an earlier account from Yahoo News had put the figure at 16 applications. That earlier count was followed by an update shared Oct. 28 describing the field as narrowed from 17 applicants down to two finalists, according to a separate Yahoo News report.

Three candidates were interviewed by community representatives and law enforcement professionals before two emerged as the strongest contenders, the Idaho News account notes. On Oct. 27, those candidates sat through two separate interview panels with law enforcement leaders and community members, a third Yahoo News article reported, with Phillips conducting his own interviews with the finalists the following day.

What Comes Next for the Finalist

Before any appointment can move forward, the finalist must pass a comprehensive background investigation, a polygraph examination and a physical fitness assessment, all of which independent third-party professionals or organizations will handle rather than city staff. The finalist will also meet with the City Council in a separate executive session, though that session is described as part of the evaluation process and not a formal nomination.

No date has been set for that executive session or for formal appointment consideration, and the finalist was not scheduled to appear before the council at its regular Monday meeting. Phillips said he will weigh the council's feedback after the executive session before deciding when to formally submit the candidate's name, with any appointment vote to follow at a later meeting.

The city is withholding both the finalist's identity and the names of the independent evaluators while the process continues. The Caldwell Police Department will keep operating under interim leadership until a chief is formally appointed, and the city has said it will share more information as the process advances and a council review timeline is set.

Under Idaho law, any executive session the council holds to discuss the appointment must be authorized by a two-thirds vote of the governing body, according to Idaho State Legislature statute, which also requires that the motion be approved through a roll-call vote recorded in the minutes.