Treasure Valley/ Community & Society

Shoshone Teen Comes Home to Duck Valley, 126 Years After Dying at Pennsylvania School

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Shoshone Teen Comes Home to Duck Valley, 126 Years After Dying at Pennsylvania SchoolSource: Google Street View

Della Tuscarora Atkins was 17 years old when she died at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania in 1900, thousands of miles from her family and the Duck Valley Indian Reservation she called home. For 126 years, her relatives in Idaho and Nevada knew almost nothing about what had happened to her. In September, her remains finally came home.

Atkins had been working in Winnemucca, Nevada, baking and cooking, before she left for Carlisle, according to KTVB. She was related to Viola Atkins as her grandfather's sister, and the family knew little about her or what became of her for generations. An autopsy attributed her cause of death to a brain tumor, with the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes citing records that pointed to complications associated with advanced brain cancer and other health problems, according to the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Historical records eventually revealed Della's name listed under the Long John family, Viola Atkins has said, according to KTVB's reporting. Her surname had been misspelled in school records, and Native News Online reports that the error is why her family was never notified of her death at the time.

Conflicting Accounts of Her Final Days

Even the basic timeline of Della's last weeks at Carlisle differs depending on the source. Native News Online and KUNR both report she arrived at the school on December 12, 1900, and died 13 days later, while ICT reports she arrived on December 13 and died 12 days after that. What is not in dispute is that she died far from the reservation she'd left behind, one of more than 190 students who died while attending Carlisle, per the dossier's reporting on Carlisle enrollment records; other outlets have put the figure differently, with the Review-Journal citing Dickinson College's count of 232 deaths, WGAL reporting at least 170, and Pennsylvania Capital-Star citing at least 168. Many of those students, like Della, died from diseases including tuberculosis and influenza.

Carlisle was the first federally funded off-reservation boarding school of its kind in the United States, operating from 1879 to 1918 and enrolling more than 7,800 students, according to the National Park Service. It was part of a federal Indian boarding school era that began in the late 1800s, Marco Ovando, public affairs officer for the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes, has said. Native American children were sent away from their families and communities during that era, as the schools were designed to assimilate them into mainstream American society, often separating children from their cultures, languages and traditions.

Bringing Della Home

The Atkins family worked with the U.S. Army to bring Della home as part of the Army's ninth repatriation mission from Carlisle's cemetery. Family members traveled to Pennsylvania to disinter her remains, Ovando has said, and after her identification was confirmed, her remains were transferred from Army custody to tribal custody. According to ICT, 58 students' remains have been returned home since the repatriation effort began in 2017.

On September 17, Della's remains were repatriated to the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes at the Duck Valley Indian Reservation, according to KIVI-TV. She was reburied the following day in a family plot at the cemetery, per KNPR. Her repatriation marked the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes' first such return from a boarding school cemetery, according to The Imprint.

A Whirlwind and a Family Reunited

Charlotte Atkins has said Della would be proud and pleased to have a huge family she never knew, according to KTVB's reporting. Charlotte also interpreted a large whirlwind near the reservation fence as a sign of Della's spiritual relatives welcoming her home.

More than 100 graves remained at Carlisle when Della was repatriated, Ovando has said. The Atkins family hopes Della's return will draw attention to the children still buried far from their families, and Viola Atkins has said families should be found for the children buried at Carlisle so they can be sent home too. She has also said everyone should know what happened at boarding schools, describing reports of sexual abuse, beatings, forced haircuts, restrictions on speaking Native languages and family separation.

Ovando has said the consequences of the boarding school era continue to affect Native communities today, pointing to the ongoing loss of language, cultural traditions and intergenerational storytelling. Carlisle's disinterment program has continued returning other students to their tribes in recent years: in October 2025, the Cheyenne and Arapaho tribes returned the remains of 16 children from the Carlisle cemetery, according to WGAL, while a separate account from The Dickinsonian put that year's total at 19 students returned to their Nations. In 2024, the remains of Eastern Shoshone boy William Neikok were also returned from Carlisle to his reservation, Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported, and the Army reported recovering and returning 11 of the 12 Carlisle students it sought to disinter this year, according to PennLive.