
The City of Calhoun and its insurance carrier have agreed to pay $1.35 million to settle a federal lawsuit filed by Christopher Cox, a former fire department employee who claimed he was fired in December 2022 after reporting sexual misconduct and refusing to falsify training records. The city says it is not admitting any wrongdoing in the case, even as it moves to cover nearly $855,000 of the payout from its own accounts.
According to Gordon Gazette, “All parties agreed to a settlement of $1.35 million from the City of Calhoun and its insurance carrier.” The city says the agreement was reached on November 2, as reported by Discover Gordon County. In its statement, the city maintained the settlement “does not constitute an admission of liability.”
Cox’s lawsuit, detailed by Northwest Georgia News, alleged he was fired in retaliation for reporting serious sexual misconduct toward a female high school student by a senior fire department leader at the fire department and other city property. He also claimed he raised concerns about abuse of authority and misuse of city property, and said he was labeled a troublemaker after bringing the complaint forward, according to the lawsuit.
Allegations of Falsified Training Records
Beyond the misconduct claims, Cox’s lawsuit alleged a separate scheme involving falsified records. Per the lawsuit, department leaders had been reporting training hours improperly, and Cox said Shift A under Roger Smith refused summer heat training and, after an Insurance Service Office audit in January 2023, lacked enough time to make up the missed hours, according to his complaint.
Cox alleged that then-Fire Chief Lenny Nesbitt, Terry Mills, and City Administrator Paul Worley conspired to falsify training-hour records so the city could pass the ISO audit — the same kind of audit that insurance carriers rely on to set rates. The lawsuit frames Cox’s firing as retaliation not just for the misconduct report but for his refusal to go along with the alleged falsification, the Gordon Gazette’s reporting on the filing shows, noting that “submitted falsified training hours to an ISO auditor so the City of Calhoun would receive a positive ISO score” was among the claims laid out in the case.
The city pushed back on those allegations early on. In a February 2024 response, the City of Calhoun denied the claims, asserting its actions were taken in good faith and without malice or reckless indifference to Cox’s protected rights.
Leadership Changes Followed Investigation
Personnel changes followed in the two years after Cox’s firing. In October 2025, Calhoun City Council accepted the resignations of Fire Chief Lenny Nesbitt and Deputy Chief Terry Mills. Both had been placed on paid administrative leave for nearly two months during a third-party investigation before stepping down. The city hired veteran fire administrator Mike Schutz as fire chief that December 2025.
Worley said the city has implemented organizational and administrative improvements since 2023 to strengthen hiring practices, personnel management, and internal accountability measures, and that the city would continue evaluating operational procedures to ensure managers receive appropriate guidance on employee-related matters. He said the city does not admit liability related to the matter and that the settlement was deemed in the city’s best interests. Discover Gordon County’s account of the city’s public statement similarly noted that organizational and administrative improvements have been implemented since 2023.
Council Approves Funding for the Payout
On November 9, Calhoun City Council approved a budget amendment totaling $854,778 to go toward the settlement payment, per the same account from Discover Gordon County. A follow-up report on the city’s finances described that figure as the city’s net liability in the Cox settlement after primary insurers submitted their payouts.
The money is being drawn from a mix of city revenue sources, including franchise taxes tied to electric, sewage, water, and telecommunications services, Local Option Sales Tax revenue, and building permit fees, the outlet’s report states. The settlement funding arrived alongside a broader round of city budget activity: two days later, on November 11, Calhoun City Council approved a series of fourth-quarter budget adjustments for Fiscal Year 2026, according to Coosa Valley News.
Those adjustments included transferring $463,767 in surplus Electric Franchise Tax revenue to several General Fund accounts, with $101,038 of that going toward police overtime. Coosa Valley News reported that the overtime expense was attributed to staffing shortages within the police department, though questions remained about why overtime costs exceeded budget projections. The same round of adjustments included an $8.56 million transfer to School SPLOST Capital Projects and a $1.15 million transfer of federal American Rescue Plan Act funding to the Water and Sewer Fund.
How Calhoun’s Payout Compares
Calhoun’s settlement lands in a similar range to other municipal fire-department retaliation cases reported elsewhere, though the evidence does not establish that these cases are directly comparable to Cox’s. California City Council approved a $1.5 million settlement in a whistleblower lawsuit filed by former fire chief Jeremy Kosick, according to KGET 17 News, though that outlet noted the agreement still needed to be formally entered before it would resolve the case without a trial.
Separately, the City of East Chicago agreed to pay $1.2 million to resolve a federal lawsuit alleging retaliation against firefighters for protected First Amendment activity, per Fire Law Blog. And in a smaller case, Kansas City approved a $175,000 settlement with deputy fire chief Nathan Dougan in a retaliation lawsuit back in September 2022, as reported by The Kansas City Star.
Calhoun Fire Department’s Station 1 is located at 327 S. Wall St. in Calhoun.









