
John “Jay” Ruskey, 53, and his wife Kristen, 49, went to a birthday party with 50 to 60 other guests at a home in Cambria on Feb. 7, 2026. By the next morning, both were dead from carbon monoxide poisoning, and a lawsuit alleges the gas escaped from a water heater in the laundry room next to the guest bedroom where they slept.
A Night That Turned Deadly
The couple, who lived in Goleta and ran Good Land Organics, an exotic fruit and coffee farm west of town, according to the San Luis Obispo Tribune, stayed overnight in a guest bedroom adjoining a laundry room that held a gas-fired tankless water heater. At approximately 4:34 a.m. on Feb. 8, Kristen called 911 after Jay began showing seizure-like symptoms, vomiting and other signs of severe distress, according to the complaint later filed in the case and cited by KTLA. Kristen reportedly told responding paramedics that Jay had eaten a chocolate bar containing psychedelic mushrooms and seemed to be having a bad reaction, an account attributed to the Santa Barbara Independent. Paramedics recommended Jay go to a hospital for further evaluation, but he declined treatment.
Hours later, around 9:30 a.m., other guests checked on the couple and found Kristen lying unresponsive on the laundry room floor and Jay in the bed, not breathing, according to The Santa Barbara Independent. The San Luis Obispo County Sheriff's Office determined that Jay died from the toxic effects of carbon monoxide, while Kristen died from the toxic effects of carbon monoxide and ethyl alcohol. The coroner ruled both deaths accidental.
Investigators Found a Disconnected Detector
Investigators confirmed that a combination smoke and carbon monoxide detector was present in the bedroom but had been disconnected, the Tribune reports. That detail now sits at the center of a lawsuit filed Oct. 26, 2026, in San Luis Obispo County Superior Court by the Ruskeys' three children, including 19-year-old Kasurina and 16-year-old twins Aiden and Sean, against both the Cambria homeowners and the manufacturer of the water heater.
The complaint, obtained via Courthouse News, alleges that a defective exhaust system on the Navien-brand tankless water heater allowed carbon monoxide to escape into the laundry room and adjoining guest bedroom instead of venting outdoors. It further alleges that repeated hot-water use by overnight guests caused the heater to run frequently, potentially filling the enclosed spaces with carbon monoxide. The children accuse Navien Inc., based in Irvine, and its South Korean parent company Kyung Dong Navien, of failing to design a system that would automatically shut down if its exhaust vent malfunctioned. Attorneys for the children also accuse homeowners Ben and Robin Korman of failing to maintain working carbon monoxide detectors in the home.
Past Recalls Cited, Though Link to This Case Unclear
The lawsuit points to a history of safety actions against Navien water heaters. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recalled roughly 13,000 Navien tankless units in December 2011 over vent connections that could separate and create a carbon monoxide hazard, according to the complaint. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission later announced another recall covering about 3,400 Navien units in 2018 over a different issue involving a conversion kit. It remains unclear whether the water heater involved in the Ruskeys' deaths was covered by either recall.
The complaint draws comparisons to other cases involving the same manufacturer. The Independent reports that relatives of a family of four who died at home in 2020 alleged that a poorly designed exhaust pipe on a Navien unit contributed to their deaths. Separately, a federal lawsuit filed Feb. 3, 2026 alleged that a gas-powered Navien water heater vented lethal concentrations of carbon monoxide into a Belize resort suite, killing three vacationing women, per the same outlet.
Family Seeks Damages, Expert Urges Caution
The Ruskey children are seeking unspecified damages for wrongful death, negligence and product liability. According to the Los Angeles Times, attorney David Shay described the deaths as preventable and urged families to install and regularly test carbon monoxide detectors in their homes. Neither Navien nor the homeowners responded to requests for comment from the Times.
The complaint brings claims for design and manufacturing defects, failure to warn, products-liability negligence, premises liability and negligence, according to the filing. The complaint alleges that the water heater's exhaust defect and the disconnected detector may have played a role in the deaths.









