
Big John's Plaza, the shopping center that's anchored Cape Coral since 1960, has new owners for the first time in 36 years. The 53,648-square-foot property at 1201-1317 Cape Coral Parkway East sold for $10.49 million, closing out an era for the family that ran it since 1990.
The sale, reported by Gulfshore Business, closed on November 17 when seller Elmer Tabor handed the property to Atacama Holdings LLC, a company managed by Andres Brown of Naples. Tabor, who bought the plaza for $1.7 million in March 1990, said he decided to sell because his family was not interested in managing the center going forward.
Tabor's connection to the property runs deep. He is the grandson of original developer Harold Davis “Andy” Anderson and had been involved with the plaza since he was 8 years old, according to the same report. His grandfather had a winter getaway in Fort Myers Beach in 1955 and was in Cape Coral when the Rosen brothers began building in 1957. Tabor's father owned a grocery store in West Virginia and was asked about relocating it to Cape Coral.
From 13 Families to a Regional Hub
Cape Coral's roots trace back to land developers Jack and Leonard Rosen, who started building the city in 1957. The Cape Coral Shopping Plaza, later renamed Big John's Plaza and also known as South Cape Towne Center, was dedicated on August 20, 1960. When Anderson asked Tabor's father about relocating the grocery store, Cape Coral had 13 families. Today, Cape Coral's population exceeds 220,000.
Elmer's Supermarket served as the plaza's original anchor tenant. The property now spans five buildings and had 20 tenants as of an April report from the Cape Coral Breeze, which also noted the center underwent a complete renovation in 2019 and got a new roof in 2023. Tenants have included Pinch A Penny, South Cape Diner, JP's Royal Jewelry, The Greek Spot, Tropical Furniture Gallery, Ralph's Place, and the “world famous” cigar bar, with the No. 3 Craft Beer Bar sitting at the plaza's eastern end.
A Deal That Took Nearly a Year
The plaza had been on the market since January 2026, originally listed at $12.49 million before ultimately closing at $10.49 million. Jack Martin, a CCIM broker with Century 21 Commercial Selling Paradise who represented Tabor, said the cap rate and rental income did not justify the additional $2 million in asking price. Still, he told Gulfshore Business, “We had many, many offers and just a ton of interest in the property.”The report notes that the plaza's listed asking price when the Cape Coral Breeze first covered the sale attempt was $12,495,000 for the 2.02-acre site. Matt Fredrickson and Doug Olson, partners at Trinity Commercial Group, represented buyer Atacama Holdings LLC in the deal.
For Andres Brown, a 2010 graduate of Barron Collier High School, the purchase comes with an acknowledgment of what came before. “We appreciate the history of the center and Elmer's family,” Brown said, per the same report. He added that Atacama Holdings plans to preserve the center's history and traditions, saying, “We look forward to continuing those traditions and making it better.” Those traditions include an annual Christmas tree lighting ceremony and the Cape Coral Art Festival, which takes place each January.
Hurricane Ian's Lasting Mark — and a Missing Statue
The plaza's recent history includes a costly recovery from Hurricane Ian, which Tabor said caused about $3.2 million in damage in September 2022. Insurance covered all but $800,000 of the repairs, and the center reopened roughly three months after the storm, though the full rebuild took 18 months to complete, according to Tabor's account relayed by Gulfshore Business.
One piece of the property still hasn't been restored: the plaza's namesake Big John statue, which has been missing since 2024, according to a News-Press report from May. Clint Strand of Brand 1 Ink has been repairing and repainting the statue, and he said it was close to finished, though he could not guarantee a return date.
Part of a Broader Cape Coral Retail Rush
The sale lands amid a notable uptick in Cape Coral retail investment activity. Transactions in the city jumped 34% by number and 102% by dollar volume in the fourth quarter of 2025, the strongest showing since the second quarter of 2024, according to a market report from CRE Consultants. The same report found Lee County retail asking rates climbed 3.0% quarter over quarter and 2.3% year over year.
Big John's Plaza isn't the only Cape Coral shopping center to change hands this year. The Shops at Surfside, a 117,556-square-foot center on 8.26 acres, sold for $12.3 million in June to Trifon Houvardas, owner and broker of Foresight Property Services, according to the Business Observer. That property was fully occupied at the time of its listing and had been purchased for $7 million by a Naples-based LLC back in 2021.









