
St. Louis County’s Board of Equalization has ruled that Chesterfield does not qualify for a property-tax exemption on the MassMutual office complex, a decision that could leave the city facing property-tax costs. The city had sought an exemption for the property.
The county board’s decision, reported by STLtoday.com, concerns the city's request for a property-tax exemption on an office complex near Central Park.
The dispute centers on whether parts of the property used for public purposes qualify for an exemption. The county Board of Equalization handles property-tax appeals.
The City's Case for an Exemption
A tax-exempt legal opinion figured in the city’s case for the purchase.
The building’s estimated real estate-tax expense is about $450,000.
A Deal With a Contested History
The Chesterfield City Council voted 6-2 on a Monday night to buy the office complex, which was proposed for future use and includes parking next to Central Park.
The city estimated rental income of more than $2.5 million and net positive annual revenue of about $543,807. The complex has existing tenants.
The purchase was controversial from the start. An earlier report from STLtoday.com described Chesterfield’s deal as $3 million over the property’s appraisal and cited a 6-2 council vote and a $17.3 million price tag for the office building; critics said the city was overpaying for property it did not need.
Public Use at Issue
Pat Tocco said only portions of the property used for public purposes might qualify for an exemption.
Property-Tax Costs
Chesterfield would need to keep paying taxes on the building.
The dispute also arrives as scrutiny of the county’s appeals process intensifies. The Missouri state auditor opened an investigation into St. Louis County’s property-tax appeals process after whistleblowers raised concerns about its fairness, according to STLPR. The county created a second Board of Equalization back in 2021 with the goal of speeding up the appeals process, and the auditor’s review is examining whether which board hears a case affects a taxpayer’s odds of winning.









