San Diego/ Politics & Govt

Chula Vista's Cannabis Permit Fight Drags Into Seventh Year After Court Reversal

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Chula Vista's Cannabis Permit Fight Drags Into Seventh Year After Court ReversalSource: WeaponizingArchitecture / Wikimedia Commons

A legal fight over who gets to sell legal weed in Chula Vista has dragged on for seven years, survived multiple court losses for the city, and still has no end in sight. At the center of it is Laura Wilkinson Sinton, a small business owner from Coronado whose company, CV Amalgamated LLC, has been trying since 2019 to land one of the city's tightly capped cannabis storefront licenses — and has yet to get one.

A Capped System Built for Conflict

Chula Vista's cannabis ordinance caps storefront retail licenses at eight citywide, with no more than two allowed in each of the city's four council districts, according to a California Court of Appeal opinion. The city's municipal code also sets out cannabis licensing rules, per Chula Vista Municipal Code. The rules were meant to require background checks and merit-based scoring of every applicant, but Sinton and her lawyers claim the city violated its own licensing process and then failed to comply with a court order requiring it to fix the problem, as reported by the San Diego Union-Tribune.

Sinton's company, then operating under the name Caligrown, sought storefront permits in council Districts One, Three and Four in 2019 and 2020, according to Voice of San Diego. The city rejected those bids, and CV Amalgamated sued in September 2020, according to the Court of Appeal opinion. The lawsuit accused Chula Vista officials of failing to follow their own rules when scoring her application.

Appeals Court Reversed Trial Court Once

The California Court of Appeal reversed the trial court's judgment once, directing the city to reassess CV Amalgamated's applications in Districts One, Three and Four. The appellate decision came in 2022. The panel also denied Chula Vista's request for a rehearing, its motion to introduce new evidence and its request for judicial notice; those denials were not a second reversal, according to the same opinion.

The city said in court papers that it fully complied with the 2022 appellate ruling. Chula Vista's lawyers told appellate judges that the trial court had declined CV Amalgamated's invitation to go further, and the city argued that the ruling required reinstatement and reassessment of the application — not an automatic license award or a halt to other permits, per the Union-Tribune's reporting.

Rescored, Ranked High, Still Rejected

A rescoring process ranked CV Amalgamated as the top applicant in one of Chula Vista's four council districts and second-highest in another, the Union-Tribune reports. Yet the company was dismissed during the second phase of the follow-up assessment and was never awarded a license. The applications also became the subject of a federal case, detailed in the U.S. District Court order.

That same federal complaint alleged the city delayed processing CV Amalgamated's applications until after it had already handed out every available retail cannabis license. The federal court ultimately granted Chula Vista's motion to dismiss the case in February 2025, though the broader state court dispute remains unresolved. CV Amalgamated also filed a separate lawsuit seeking damages estimated at no less than $13,842,281.81, per the Union-Tribune.

A Rival Dispensary Enters the Fray

March and Ash, a company that operates 10 or more marijuana dispensaries across San Diego County and beyond, was approved for two of Chula Vista's cannabis licenses — prompting CV Amalgamated to add the company as a real party in interest in its lawsuit, according to the Union-Tribune. March and Ash's lawyers argued in a reply brief to the 4th District Court of Appeal that Chula Vista complied with the initial court order simply by rescoring the application, and separately argued that processing an application does not guarantee a license will follow.

The newspaper also reports that March and Ash donated more than $360,000 to state and local officials over four years, including a $10,000 donation to Chula Vista for the mayor and council's 2023 swearing-in ceremony and reception.

Accusations of a Rigged Process

Attorney David S. Demian said Chula Vista adopted competitive cannabis licensing laws and then arbitrarily broke them, and separately said the city litigated the case at high cost while secretly issuing licenses to selected applicants, according to the Union-Tribune. Chula Vista has been accused in lawsuits of arbitrarily and secretly granting cannabis licenses, while the city has argued in court papers that CV Amalgamated is really trying to displace existing licensees and obtain permits beyond what the ordinance allows.

Chula Vista officials declined to respond to questions about the cannabis ordinance and declined to comment on the escalating legal dispute; city officials and lawyers also refused to disclose the dispute's taxpayer cost or explain why particular licenses were approved or denied, according to the Union-Tribune. The city does not publish the status of pending cannabis applications.

A City Council Seat, a Political Consulting Firm, and a Federal Case

The dispute has also brushed up against a separate federal criminal case. Andrea Cardenas served on the Chula Vista City Council when most of the city's cannabis permits were approved and participated in closed-session discussions over the cannabis litigation, the Union-Tribune reports. Cardenas also worked at Grassroots Resources, a political consulting firm run by her brother, Jesus Cardenas, that represented marijuana businesses. Andrea Cardenas and Jesus Cardenas were charged in 2023 with defrauding the federal government and initially pleaded not guilty; Andrea Cardenas resigned from the city council in February 2024 and pleaded guilty days later, according to the newspaper. The Union-Tribune reports that federal agents reportedly executed search warrants at the homes of Jesus Cardenas and Kelvin Barrios this month and seized computers and other devices as part of the criminal investigation.

A Separate Clemency Episode Tied to the City's First License

Chula Vista issued its first cannabis license to Andres Camberos and the Grasshopper dispensary, the Union-Tribune reports. Camberos later asked then-Chula Vista councilmember John McCann for help obtaining a presidential commutation for his sister, Adriana Camberos, who had been sentenced to 26 months in prison for a counterfeit 5-hour energy drinks scheme. McCann wrote to the president requesting clemency, and said at the time that Adriana Camberos deserved to be set free and did not fully know about the scheme; the clemency request was later approved. Andres Camberos and Adriana Camberos each donated the maximum $360 to McCann's 2022 mayoral campaign, according to the newspaper, and the pair was later indicted in a separate 2023 fraud case and convicted of fraud similar to Adriana Camberos' earlier case.

Where the Case Stands Now

The litigation remains in its seventh year and still awaits a hearing before the 4th District Court of Appeal, with oral arguments likely to be docketed sometime in the first half of 2027, according to the Union-Tribune. The Chula Vista City Council may vote to expand the number of cannabis permits available in the city, though no such vote has occurred as of this reporting.

Chula Vista's cannabis ordinance caps storefront licenses at eight. California first empowered local governments to license and regulate marijuana in 2017. For Sinton, a small business owner who later ran an unsuccessful campaign for Coronado City Council in 2024, the fight over a single storefront permit has become a years-long test of whether the city will answer for how it ran its own licensing process.