
More than four years after a woman walking her dog stumbled on a severed human head stuffed in a trash bag in Foresthill's Todd Valley area, investigators say they finally know who he was — and who they believe killed him. Placer County Sheriff's Office detectives arrested a 45-year-old woman on a murder charge Tuesday and her 75-year-old mother on accessory charges, alleging that the daughter killed 73-year-old Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. at a Citrus Heights home and her mother helped dispose of his remains.
Deputies first responded to the Todd Valley discovery on Sept. 28, 2022, according to KCRA, which reported that the head was found by a resident out walking her dog. At the time, officials could not identify the remains because of the state of decomposition, and Fitzmaurice had not even been reported missing, the station noted. With no leads from a missing-persons report and no hits when investigators entered the victim's DNA into CODIS, investigators continued trying to identify him.
Forensic Science Fills in a Face
Investigators eventually turned to forensic specialists at California State University, Chico, who developed a preliminary age and race profile from the victim's skull and created an artist's rendering of the unidentified man, according to the Folsom Times. That effort still wasn't enough to put a name to the remains, so in January 2024 detectives submitted the victim's DNA to Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing, the outlet reported.
Othram's genealogical profile pointed investigators toward possible distant relatives, and the FBI stepped in to help trace the family tree, per the same account. FBI agents assisted by interviewing those distant relatives and collecting DNA samples for comparison — work that ultimately led detectives to identify the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who was 73 years old at the time of his death and had last been known to live in Citrus Heights with his wife and adult daughter.
How Genetic Genealogy Cracks Cold Cases
The technique that broke this case open works differently than the DNA matching most people are familiar with. Investigative genetic genealogy can identify distant genetic relatives of an unknown individual, whereas traditional forensic DNA testing generally compares evidence directly against a known person, according to the BBC. It is a combination of DNA analysis and paper-trail research that has been used over the past decade to reverse-engineer a person's identity, as CNN has reported, a method distinct from the FBI's traditional Combined DNA Index System, which compares a sample against all known offenders.
The approach has produced breakthroughs well beyond Placer County. CNN reported that Tiffany Bradley was identified nearly 26 years after her murder through genetic genealogy, and the BBC noted the same technique helped identify a suspect in the 1993 killing of Randy Gail Sperino after crime-scene DNA turned up no matches in law enforcement databases. Closer to home, CBS Sacramento reported that advanced DNA technology identified a woman named Patricia Rose nearly 40 years after her death in another Placer County cold case, with Othram Lab saying its sequencing can trace relatives as far as sixth cousins.
Search Warrant Leads to Arrests
With Fitzmaurice finally identified, detectives moved on the people investigators believe were responsible. On Tuesday, Placer County Sheriff's Office detectives served a search warrant at the family's residence on Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights, according to the Folsom Times. Investigators believe that Mary Fitzmaurice was responsible for Paul's murder at the Citrus Heights home, and that Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice helped dispose of his remains, KCRA reported.
Mary Fitzmaurice was booked on a murder charge, while Gwenn Fitzmaurice was booked on accessory charges, the Folsom Times reported. The Placer County Sheriff's Office announced the arrests in a post on X titled “Cold Case Breakthrough: Foresthill Severed Head Identified; Mother and Daughter Arrested for Murder.” The criminal charges against both women remain allegations pending resolution in court, and authorities said no motive has been established; KCRA also reported that no remains beyond Paul's head have been located.









