Greater Madison/ Crime & Emergencies

Clark County Homicide Case Splits Local Reports on Court Status

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Clark County Homicide Case Splits Local Reports on Court StatusClark County Circuit Court — Site of Conflicting Trial Reports
Google Street View

Victor Manuel Gomez Acosta, 31, is accused of killing his two children and trying to kill their mother at the family's Abbotsford mobile home in July 2024. On Monday, Clark County coverage of the case did not agree on whether a judge or a jury was hearing it.

WSAU reported that a bench trial was underway before a Clark County judge, with no jury, and that the proceedings were expected to last through Friday. News 8 Now had reported that court records scheduled a jury trial to begin the same day, Nov. 16.

What Investigators Allege

Investigators say Gomez Acosta stabbed the children at their Abbotsford home on July 5, 2024, and stabbed their mother. News 8 Now, citing the criminal complaint, reported that the children were found dead in their bedroom. They died from the stab wounds.

The complaint, as reported by News 8 Now, said their mother had injuries that required surgery. WSAU reported that she later recovered. Gomez Acosta was treated for stab wounds and booked into the Clark County Jail, that station also reported.

He faces two counts of first-degree intentional homicide and one count of attempted first-degree intentional homicide. News 8 Now reported that he remained in custody on a $1 million cash bond.

Competency, Then a Return to Court

The case stopped for a time on the question of whether Gomez Acosta could stand trial. In September 2024 he was found incompetent, and Judge Lyndsey Brunette ordered involuntary treatment for a period not to exceed 12 months, the Leader-Telegram reported.

In June 2025, a judge approved requests from both the defense and the prosecution for more tests, WSAW reported. News 8 Now later reported that a judge ruled him competent after a competency evaluation.

WSAU also reported that he pleaded not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect.

September Accounts That Do Not Match

Two September reports describe different results from his pleas. Seehafer News reported on Sept. 8 that he had been found guilty after a no-contest plea on the homicide and attempted-homicide charges.

The Leader-Telegram reported that the court accepted his pleas but withheld entering them, and that a conviction of not guilty due to mental disease or defect remained in place. Those are not two ways of saying the same thing.

Life in Prison, If the Case Is Still Open

WSAU reported that a guilty finding would carry a mandatory life sentence on each count, with the possibility of parole left to the judge’s discretion. News 8 Now reported that conviction on all charges would mean life in prison.

That penalty language only fits a case still waiting on guilt. Seehafer News, two months earlier, already described a guilty finding. Monday's local reports still do not settle whether a judge is hearing the case alone or a jury was set to begin.