Capital Region/ Crime & Emergencies

Colonie Mom Faces Family Court Deadline Over Mixed-Up CPS Case, Threat to Lose Kids

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Colonie Mom Faces Family Court Deadline Over Mixed-Up CPS Case, Threat to Lose KidsShaker Road Elementary School — Reported School Portal Message Origin
Google Street View

A Colonie mother known in reports as J.F. says a mix-up in her daughter's school records — stemming from another parent who shares her exact first and last name — spiraled into a Child Protective Services investigation that now threatens to land her in family court. She says a caseworker showed up at her home last month asking about a child she insists her family has never met.

According to WRGB, the trouble began in January 2024, shortly after J.F. moved her daughter into the South Colonie Central School District. She says she started receiving school communications meant for a different child, including older portal messages intended for another student — one of which, written by a teacher the previous November, noted that the student had not submitted a paper rough draft on time and would need to finish it over Thanksgiving break. J.F. says she emailed the district multiple times about the misdirected message but never got a response, and she separately flagged to the school that her portal email address appeared to be linked to another family's account.

Calls, Forms, and a Child She Says She Doesn't Know

The mix-up didn't stop there, per the outlet's report. J.F. says she received phone calls about the other parent's daughter missing class and forgetting school supplies, and in March 2024 got a school nurse message requesting updated medical forms for that same other child. She says she made multiple reports to the school's IT department about the account mix-up, and that the problem had continued for years.

Then, on October 19, a CPS caseworker showed up at J.F.'s home. The caseworker allegedly expected to find three or four children in the household — J.F. says she has only two — and asked her to identify everyone living there. According to J.F.'s account, the caseworker showed her a report concerning the other family's child. The caseworker did not ask to speak with or examine J.F.'s daughter but did ask to look around the home.

Letters, a Questionnaire, and a Warning

J.F. and her husband say they received letters stating they were under investigation and needed to complete a Family Assessment Response. When J.F. called CPS for an explanation, she says she was told the school had filed its original report for the other parent after a teacher noticed bruises on the other child's wrist — and that the report had somehow been misrouted to her family instead.

J.F. says a CPS caseworker later pressed her to complete a questionnaire. She says she asked the school to hand over her own daughter's nurse records to help clear up the confusion, but the school declined to provide them. Frustrated, J.F. reported the caseworker to Colonie police for harassment; police told her they could do little since no crime had been committed, though they did confirm that neither she nor her husband had any criminal background on record, the station reports.

CPS has reportedly given J.F. a deadline of December 14 to comply, warning that the case will move to family court if she does not. J.F. says she is prepared to contest the matter in court if it comes to that.

What the School District and CPS Are Saying

CPS, for its part, said it could not comment on any existing or nonexistent report.

New York's statewide guidance on Family Assessment Response — the track CPS reportedly offered J.F. — states that participation is voluntary. According to the Office of Children and Family Services, “Participation in FAR is voluntary. When a caseworker offers to respond to a CPS report with FAR, the subject… can always choose to have the CPS respond with a traditional investigation instead.”

Attorney Points to Potential Liability

Greg Rinckey, an attorney at Tully Rinckey PLLC, told the station that both the school district and Albany County CPS could face liability in a case like this, including emotional-distress damages.

The legal exposure Rinckey describes echoes older case law in New York weighing when those who report suspected child maltreatment are shielded from liability. In a 2009 case, Biondo v. Ossining Union Free School District, defendants sought immunity under state Social Services Law after reporting a suspected child-maltreatment incident, while the plaintiffs argued the defendants lacked reasonable cause to suspect abuse and acted in bad faith. The New York appellate court modified the lower-court order by dismissing the inadequate hiring, training, and supervision claim against the school district and otherwise affirmed the order insofar as appealed from; it also found triable issues concerning reasonable cause and good faith.

For now, J.F. says she's left trying to prove a negative — that her family has no connection to a case built on someone else's name — while a December 14 deadline looms over whether the matter heads to family court.