Denver/ Politics & Govt

Colorado Appeals Court Says Wildlife Agency Illegally Ignored 191 Public Comments

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Colorado Appeals Court Says Wildlife Agency Illegally Ignored 191 Public Comments6060 Broadway — Colorado Wildlife Agency Appeal
Google Street View

Colorado Parks and Wildlife broke state law when it changed the rules governing access to state wildlife areas in 2023, according to a ruling the Colorado Court of Appeals issued Thursday. The court found that the agency opened an online comment period, collected 191 website comments and seven emails over six weeks, and then never included that feedback in the official rulemaking record or let the decision-makers who finalized the rules consider it.

Court Reverses Earlier Ruling That Sided With the Agency

The decision reverses a district court ruling that had found CPW's rules did not arbitrarily favor hunters and fishers and substantially complied with state rulemaking law. According to Colorado Public Radio, the appeals court concluded that CPW violated the rulemaking provisions of the State Administrative Procedure Act when it failed to include the online comments in the record or weigh them in the final rules. The law requires that public comments become part of the rulemaking record and actually get considered before an agency finalizes new regulations.

Colorado’s rulemaking statute requires agencies to maintain a public record that includes written submissions and comments received by the rulemaking hearing. It also says a rule is invalid unless adopted in substantial compliance with the statute. The requirements make the comment record part of the legal process for adopting rules, not simply an outreach exercise, as set out in Colorado’s Administrative Procedure Act.

The court also found that CPW invited public comment through an online platform, Engage CPW, that was never mentioned in the agency's official notice of rulemaking. CPW itself conceded in the case that comments submitted through that platform were never presented to or considered by the agency decision-makers who ultimately approved the final rules, the outlet reported.

What the 2023 Rule Changes Actually Did

CPW released its proposed changes for public comment through Engage CPW in April 2023, following a proposal from the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission that was meant to address concerns that increased recreational use could harm wildlife. The final rules made certain state wildlife areas off-limits to people who wanted to simply observe wildlife, while still allowing hunters and fishers into those same areas. Some of the proposed regulations also would have allowed hunting dogs into areas where people and their own dogs were barred.

The dispute affects a system of about 350 state wildlife areas across Colorado. The areas may be state- or privately owned, are managed for wildlife, and are funded by sportspersons; CPW says permitted activities vary by property, though most focus on hunting and fishing. Access rules also require visitors age 16 and older to carry a hunting or fishing license or a State Wildlife Area pass, according to CPW’s State Wildlife Area guidance.

Online commenters pushed back hard on that framework during the comment window. Some argued the rules unfairly favored hunters and fishers over other users and could harm wildlife and habitat by prioritizing those activities, while others raised concerns about hunting dogs being allowed where pet dogs could not go. One commenter who lived in Carbondale called fishing and hunting restrictions along the Roaring Fork unfair, and another asked that all users have equal access along the Roaring Fork River between Aspen and Glenwood Springs. A separate commenter asked that non-motorized boaters be allowed into the areas for recreational boating access. CPW itself estimated, according to the court opinion, that only about a quarter of Engage CPW commenters generally agreed with the proposed changes.

Three Groups Took CPW to Court

Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness, and Living River filed the lawsuit that led to Thursday's ruling, challenging CPW's new rules. Attorney Stephen Hernick, who represented the three groups, said he was concerned the rules discriminated against people who wanted to observe wildlife without hunting or fishing, and argued that CPW prioritized hunting and fishing over other wildlife-related recreation. Hernick said he hoped the agency would now reconsider the public comments it set aside and go back to the drawing board.

CPW manages roughly 350 lands and waters designated by the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission for wildlife and public wildlife viewing, making the outcome of this case relevant well beyond the specific areas named in the lawsuit. In an emailed statement, CPW said it was still evaluating the Colorado Court of Appeals' decision and determining its next steps.

The appellate court’s formal disposition was to reverse the Denver district court’s judgment and send the case back with directions, rather than issue a new statewide access policy. The published decision identifies the case as No. 25CA2144, Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness and Living Rivers v. Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission and Division of Parks and Wildlife. The court’s case announcement lists the judgment as reversed and remanded.