Denver/ Crime & Emergencies

Colorado Appeals Court Upholds Vehicle Theft Law in Adams County Case

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Colorado Appeals Court Upholds Vehicle Theft Law in Adams County CaseColorado Court of Appeals — Issued Vehicle Theft Law Ruling
Google Street View

A Colorado Court of Appeals panel has upheld the conviction of Rudy Levi Hurtado, rejecting his argument that the state’s first-degree motor vehicle theft law unconstitutionally treats repeat offenders differently than other defendants. The unanimous ruling, decided Thursday, keeps intact a 12-year community corrections sentence handed down after an Adams County jury convicted Hurtado in 2024.

Hurtado was charged under Colorado Revised Statutes § 18-4-409(2), a law that requires prosecutors to prove two prior convictions involving motor vehicle theft or unauthorized use of a vehicle as part of the offense itself, rather than as a sentencing factor decided later by a judge, according to Colorado Lawyer. His defense asked the trial court to bifurcate the proceedings so jurors would first weigh the current charge before hearing about his criminal history, but the trial judge denied that request, as reported by Colorado Politics. Jurors did receive a limiting instruction before the prior convictions were introduced at trial, per the same account.

Equal Protection Argument Rejected

On appeal, attorney Lindsey Parlin argued that the 2023 law violated Hurtado’s equal-protection rights by making prior convictions an element jurors must consider, rather than a sentence enhancer proven separately to a judge. Parlin contended the jury was repeatedly reminded of Hurtado’s past vehicle theft convictions throughout the trial, raising the risk that he was convicted based on his history rather than the facts of the charged offense, the Colorado Politics report states. Hurtado himself argued that hearing evidence of his prior convictions alongside the current charge unfairly damaged his defense.

To bolster the challenge, Parlin contrasted the vehicle theft statute with Colorado’s animal cruelty law, which treats prior convictions differently. But the appeals panel found that comparison didn’t hold up, concluding that a defendant charged with first-degree motor vehicle theft is not similarly situated to a defendant charged with animal cruelty, according to Colorado Lawyer. The panel ruled that the two statutes concern entirely different conduct, so treating prior convictions differently under each law does not violate equal protection.

Judge Dunn’s Written Opinion

Judge Stephanie Dunn authored the opinion for the three-judge panel, which also included Judges Timothy J. Schutz and Kyle Brenton, ruling 3-0 to reject Hurtado’s constitutional challenge. Dunn wrote that Hurtado’s real objection centered on the legislature’s choice to make prior convictions an element of first-degree vehicle theft instead of a separate sentence enhancer, per Colorado Politics. She acknowledged that hearing evidence of the alleged offense and the prior convictions together at the same trial was a valid concern, but found it did not amount to a constitutional violation.

Dunn wrote that equal protection law addresses differential treatment of similarly situated individuals, and since vehicle theft and animal cruelty defendants are not similarly situated, the differing treatment of prior convictions under those statutes does not violate Hurtado’s rights. The opinion also noted that the Colorado legislature has the power to define criminal conduct and establish the legal components of criminal liability, according to Colorado Politics.

How the 2023 Law Changed Penalties

Colorado lawmakers changed the motor vehicle theft law in 2023, restructuring how the crime is classified. Under the current version, the law imposes a more severe felony classification when a defendant has prior vehicle theft convictions, rather than basing severity on the value of the stolen vehicle, as reported by the Denver Gazette.

The Hurtado case is separate from a related constitutional fight now before the Colorado Supreme Court, People v. Ruiz, which concerns different language in the same law. That case asks whether the statute’s “reasonably should have known” phrasing permits a conviction without proof that a defendant actually knew a vehicle was stolen, according to the Denver Gazette’s coverage of oral arguments. The Ruiz case does not raise the equal-protection issue decided in Hurtado, and its outcome had not been determined as of that reporting.

For now, the Court of Appeals’ ruling leaves Colorado’s 2023 vehicle theft framework intact against this particular constitutional challenge, affirming both the legal structure of the statute and Hurtado’s judgment of conviction.