
At a Cranston meeting, the Zoning Board unanimously denied the Rhode Island Shriners' application to keep its existing LED sign, while voting 4-1 to approve the group's outdoor patio extension. The split decision caps months of neighborhood complaints over noise, lighting and what critics called a pattern of building first and asking permission later.
Neighbors objected to the digital sign, and Council Member Bridget Graziano questioned its fit with the historic character of the neighborhood, according to Warwick Beacon. The sign sits on Broad Street at the gateway to a national historic district.
That error traced back to a simple miscommunication, according to planning staff member James Ray, who told Cranston's Plan Commission at a Tuesday meeting that the permit was issued in error because the person issuing it was not made aware it was an LED sign, which is not allowed in any zone in the city, as reported by upriseri.com. Jonathan Stevens, addressing the same commission, put a number on the violation: the sign is 33 and a third square feet where six is allowed. The commission had already voted by voice to recommend against both the sign and patio applications, though that recommendation was advisory and left the final call to the Zoning Board.
Patio Survives, But Only With Conditions
The Zoning Board approved the Shriners' pre-existing outdoor patio, with its covered food and beverage areas, subject to stipulations. One board member cast the lone vote against the patio. The patio structures were built without permits or inspections.
The Shriners building sits in a residential zone. The patio and bar remain subject to city licensing.
Council Member Says Shriners Built First, Asked Later
Ward 1 Councilwoman Bridget Graziano opposed both applications, citing concerns raised by neighbors, and told the board that this application is asking for forgiveness, not for permission. At the Plan Commission meeting, Graziano had also said the patio structures were built without permits and inspections, and Stevens separately noted that police were called over amplified music at a June outdoor concert.
Sign Dispute Headed Back To Municipal Court
The sign dispute has simmered for months — as far back as August, city council members said at a meeting that the sign remained illuminated even as its legal status was disputed, per the earlier report from upriseri.com. An assistant city solicitor said at that same meeting he did not believe a cease-and-desist order had actually gone out, while Councilman Traficante said he understood an arrangement had been reached allowing the sign to remain lit until 9 p.m., though officials disputed how that arrangement originated.
Residents have criticized the sign for its brightness, raised public-safety concerns and argued it simply doesn't belong in a historic district and residential zone. With the Zoning Board's denial, the fight over the Edgewood neighborhood landmark continues.









