
After five years of surveys, workshops and design revisions, the Downtown DeLand CRA board voted 5-1 on Nov. 2 to approve the cheapest of four options for the long-discussed West Voorhis Avenue Streetscape project. Alternative 4 adds four-way stop signs, extended intersection curbs and brick crosswalks at South Florida Avenue and Voorhis Avenue, but leaves most of the rest of the block untouched.
The decision came after years of public input, as detailed by The West Volusia Beacon, which reported that Garcia Civil Contractors submitted the lowest estimated bid, at $348,004.75, among eight companies competing for the work. That price tag stands in stark contrast to the far pricier alternatives the board passed over: Alternative 1, the full streetscape option including road narrowing, expanded pedestrian access and a replacement traffic signal at Clara and Voorhis, carried an estimated cost of $1,734,463.77. Alternative 2, a partial streetscape between South Clara and South Florida avenues, was estimated at $1,243,607.15, while Alternative 3, covering the segment between South Florida Avenue and South Woodland Boulevard, came in at $867,756.69. Notably, all four alternatives included the four-way stop improvement at Florida and Voorhis.
Years of Planning Led to a Smaller Fix
The project's public process stretches back to 2021, when an online survey drew 702 responses on how the city's Community Redevelopment Agency should spend $600,000 — and streetscaping Voorhis Avenue received the most first-place votes, per the same report. The city followed up with community workshops and meetings through 2022 and 2023, and city staff returned to the CRA board in June 2023 with a final design for approval. According to a 2023-2024 Downtown Community Redevelopment Agency report from the City of DeLand, the CRA approved that final design and allocated $1,442,330 for the streetscape that fiscal year, though only $163,204.30 was actually spent.
Money ultimately drove the board toward the smaller option. The Downtown CRA has just $1,514,506 in reserves available to spend, the Beacon's account noted, and the submitted bids did not include contingency funds or city construction-oversight costs — expenses officials said could raise the price of whichever option was chosen by another 5 to 10 percent. Complicating matters further, the city had sought a federal park-and-trail grant to help cover the project's cost but did not receive it.
Board Members Split Over How Far to Go
Not every board member was ready to settle for the scaled-back version. Vice Mayor Jessica Davis favored the full Alternative 1 plan and urged colleagues to find funding for the complete project, ultimately casting the lone dissenting vote against Alternative 4. Commissioner Dan Reed instead favored the middle-ground Alternative 2, arguing that completing the full project was not fiscally responsible at this time. Commissioner Kevin Reid wanted sidewalk expansion along South Florida Avenue between Howry and Voorhis avenues prioritized before other work, while Commissioner Richard Paiva backed Alternative 4 and its four-way stop and intersection improvements. Mayor Chris Cloudman warned that completing the full project would require financing and repayment from future CRA funds. Taylor Bass was absent from the vote.
Community members weighed in as well. Joan Carter said the community favored completing the entire streetscape and prioritized the Florida-Voorhis four-way stop, while Fred Peace argued that completing the work in one contract could provide better value. In the end, the board approved Alternative 4 alongside a directive for staff to study a related sidewalk improvement.
A Lighted Path Toward Downtown, Cost Unknown
Beyond the intersection work, the DeLand City Commission directed City Manager Michael Pleus and staff to study a low-cost sidewalk connection with lighting along South Florida Avenue toward Howry Avenue and downtown DeLand. Pleus said the cost of that proposed lighted pathway is not yet known. Alternative 4 is expected to improve pedestrian, cyclist and vehicle safety at the Voorhis and Florida intersection, even as the broader streetscape vision remains unfunded for now.
A Historic Stretch of DeLand
West Voorhis Avenue runs through a historically significant stretch of DeLand that was once home to a thriving Black community, according to the Beacon's reporting. The street includes the historic Washington Theater, formerly the Booker T. Washington movie theater and now home to a Seventh-day Adventist church, along with the Greater Union First Baptist Church, built in 1893. Diagonally across sits the J.W. Wright Building, completed in 1920 and now owned and being renovated by Greater Union Life Center Inc., a nonprofit offshoot of the church. The area is also part of the DeLand Black Heritage Trail, developed by the River-to-Sea Loop Alliance, Stetson University, the West Volusia Historical Society and others.









